How their hotels score
Average, out of 20
Overall Level
Overall: Aman 17.4 out of 20, Rosewood 17.0 out of 20.Service Level
Service: Aman 17.4 out of 20, Rosewood 17.0 out of 20.Rooms & Design Level
Rooms & Design: Aman 17.7 out of 20, Rosewood 17.3 out of 20.Location Level
Location: Aman 17.5 out of 20, Rosewood 17.3 out of 20.Dining Level
Dining: Aman 16.8 out of 20, Rosewood 16.9 out of 20.Wellness +0.5
Wellness: Aman 16.9 out of 20, Rosewood 16.4 out of 20.In the same city
Their hotels
Aman 14 hotels in the collection
- Aman-i-Khas Fat Legend · 18.5/20
- Amandari Fat Legend · 18.5/20
- Amanpuri Fat Legend · 18.5/20
- Aman Nai Lert Bangkok Fat Legend · 18/20
- Amanzoe Fat Legend · 18/20
- Aman Kyoto Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Amanfayun Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Amanjena Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Aman Tokyo Fat Favorite · 17/20
- Aman Venice Fat Favorite · 17/20
- Aman Villas at Nusa Dua Fat Approved · 16.5/20
- Amangiri Fat Approved · 16.5/20
- Aman New York Fat Approved · 16/20
- Amanyara Fat Approved · 16/20
Opening next
- Amangani Late 2026
- Aman Maldives 2026-2027
- Aman Dubai 2027
- Aman Karingani 2027
Rosewood 14 hotels in the collection
- Hôtel de Crillon, A Rosewood Hotel Fat Legend · 18/20
- Rosewood Luang Prabang Fat Legend · 18/20
- Rosewood Castiglion del Bosco Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Rosewood Phuket Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- The Chancery Rosewood London Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Rosewood Bangkok Fat Favorite · 17/20
- Rosewood Beijing Fat Favorite · 17/20
- Rosewood London Fat Favorite · 17/20
- Rosewood Miramar Beach Fat Favorite · 17/20
- The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel Fat Favorite · 17/20
- Rosewood Hong Kong Fat Approved · 16.5/20
- Rosewood Schloss Fuschl Fat Approved · 16.5/20
- Rosewood Villa Magna Fat Approved · 16.5/20
- Rosewood Amsterdam Fat Approved · 15.5/20
Opening next
- Rosewood Hangzhou Late 2026
- Rosewood Shenzhen Late 2026
- Rosewood Blue Palace 2027
- Rosewood Calistoga January 2027
What fat travellers ask
Is Aman better than Rosewood?
There is little between them: Aman’s 14 hotels in the Fat Voyage collection average 17.4 out of 20 and Rosewood’s 14 average 17.0, less than half a point apart. The hotel matters more than the brand; the best of each are Aman-i-Khas and Hôtel de Crillon, A Rosewood Hotel.
Which has the better service, Aman or Rosewood?
Neither by much: Aman’s hotels average 17.4 out of 20 for service and Rosewood’s 17.0. The highest at Aman: Aman-i-Khas. At Rosewood: Hôtel de Crillon, A Rosewood Hotel and Rosewood Luang Prabang.
Which has the better rooms, Aman or Rosewood?
Neither by much: Aman’s hotels average 17.7 out of 20 for rooms & design and Rosewood’s 17.3. The highest at Aman: Aman-i-Khas and Amanzoe. At Rosewood: Hôtel de Crillon, A Rosewood Hotel and five others.
Which has the better locations, Aman or Rosewood?
Neither by much: Aman’s hotels average 17.5 out of 20 for location and Rosewood’s 17.3. The highest at Aman: Amangiri. At Rosewood: Rosewood Castiglion del Bosco.
Which has the better restaurants, Aman or Rosewood?
Neither by much: Aman’s hotels average 16.8 out of 20 for dining and Rosewood’s 16.9. The highest at Aman: Aman-i-Khas and five others. At Rosewood: Rosewood Luang Prabang and Rosewood Phuket.
Which has the better spas, Aman or Rosewood?
Aman: Aman’s hotels average 16.9 out of 20 for wellness and Rosewood’s 16.4. The highest at Aman: Amanpuri and two others. At Rosewood: Hôtel de Crillon, A Rosewood Hotel and six others.
How many Aman and Rosewood hotels are in the Fat Voyage collection?
Aman has 14 hotels in the collection (five Fat Legends, five Fat Favorites and four Fat Approved). Rosewood has 14 hotels in the collection (two Fat Legends, eight Fat Favorites and four Fat Approved).
Where do Aman and Rosewood both have a hotel?
Both have a hotel in the collection in Bangkok, New York and Phuket: in Bangkok, Aman Nai Lert Bangkok and Rosewood Bangkok; in New York, Aman New York and The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel; in Phuket, Amanpuri and Rosewood Phuket.

