Methodology
How a hotel gets its Fat Score.
We read the trip reports luxury travellers write after their stays, thousands of them, and our own engine weighs every one to find the hotels that really deliver.
What goes into a Fat Score?
What travellers wrote after they stayed: trip reports from the most active luxury travel communities, guest reviews, and the publications that still send a critic (Condé Nast Traveler, Travel + Leisure, The Telegraph, Forbes Travel Guide).
Each hotel page says how many reports stand behind its verdict.
How is the score built?
Every hotel gets one score out of 20, in half-point steps, built from five things: service, rooms & design, location, dining and wellness.
Our own engine reads every report, and pays most attention to the detailed, the credible and the recent.
- Depth over brevity
- A detailed review counts for far more than a line or two, and a trip report from the fat-travel forums counts most of all.
- Recency first
- A stay from two months ago matters more than one from three years ago.
- Consistency
- No single stay decides a hotel’s score; the same problem across several recent stays does.
Our custom technology does the heavy lifting, analysing signals at a scale no human team could match. But our team defines the rules—what it reads, how much each voice counts, and what a verdict is never allowed to say—and we step in when it gets something wrong. Technology gathers the evidence; our editorial judgment shapes how it’s read.
No hotel can score 20; the highest in the collection today is 18.5.
What do the tiers mean?
Every hotel in the collection sits in one of three tiers.
-
18 out of 20 and above
As good as a hotel gets: the hotels people plan whole trips around.
-
17 to 17.5 out of 20
The kind you go back to: hotels that get nearly everything right.
-
16 to 16.5 out of 20
In the collection, and we’d send you: the verdict says which trip each one is right for. A hotel already in the collection that slips to 15.5 stays Fat Approved.
-
What keeps a hotel out of the collection?
We don’t cover every hotel that calls itself luxury in the first place: where it is, the building and its reputation for service decide what we write about.
A hotel joins at 16.0 and only leaves the collection if it falls below 15.5, so one weaker re-score doesn’t bounce it in and out.
The score also needs the fat travel community behind it. Where they haven’t weighed in on a hotel yet, its page reads “Community score pending” and carries no Fat Score; it joins the collection when the reports arrive and back it up.
Hotels that don’t make it keep their page, so you can see why, but we never recommend them. The full directory lists every hotel we cover, including the ones outside the collection.
How often is a hotel re-scored?
Every few months, each hotel is read again in full, with everything written since added, and scored afresh from the whole three-year window.
Hotels change: a new chef, a renovation, a new manager. It all shows up in what the next guests write, so a score can move, and the tier follows.
Each hotel page gives the date its score was set. A first score usually moves once more reports arrive.
Do Fat Voyage’s own stays count?
Once. Some hotels we go and see for ourselves, and what we write afterwards is a Founders’ Verdict.
Sometimes we pay, sometimes a hotel invites us. Either way, a free night never buys a better score: our stay goes into the Fat Score as one traveller’s report, weighted the same as a detailed trip report from the fat-travel forums.