Brand against brand Belmond vs One&Only
Overall, Belmond has the stronger hotels.
Belmond for the food.
How their hotels score
Average, out of 20
Overall +0.6
Overall: Belmond 17.9 out of 20, One&Only 17.3 out of 20.Service +0.8
Service: Belmond 18.0 out of 20, One&Only 17.2 out of 20.Rooms & Design Level
Rooms & Design: Belmond 17.6 out of 20, One&Only 17.7 out of 20.Location Level
Location: Belmond 17.7 out of 20, One&Only 17.7 out of 20.Dining +1.1
Dining: Belmond 17.6 out of 20, One&Only 16.5 out of 20.Wellness Level
Wellness: Belmond 17.0 out of 20, One&Only 17.2 out of 20.In the same city
Their hotels
Belmond 7 hotels in the collection
- Belmond Hotel Caruso Fat Legend · 18.5/20
- Belmond Mount Nelson Fat Legend · 18/20
- Belmond The Cadogan Fat Legend · 18/20
- Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence Fat Legend · 18/20
- Belmond Copacabana Palace Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Hotel Cipriani, A Belmond Hotel, Venice Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- La Residencia, A Belmond Hotel Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
Opening next
One&Only 6 hotels in the collection
- One&Only Cape Town Fat Legend · 18/20
- One&Only The Palm Fat Legend · 18/20
- One&Only One Za’abeel Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- One&Only Reethi Rah Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- One&Only Mandarina Fat Favorite · 17/20
- One&Only Palmilla Fat Approved · 16/20
Opening next
- One&Only Antigua 2027
- One&Only Hudson Valley 2028
- One&Only Fiji 2029
- One&Only Courchevel 2030
What fat travellers ask
Is Belmond better than One&Only?
On average, yes: Belmond’s seven hotels in the Fat Voyage collection average 17.9 out of 20 and One&Only’s six average 17.3. The best of each: Belmond Hotel Caruso and One&Only Cape Town.
Which has the better service, Belmond or One&Only?
Belmond: Belmond’s hotels average 18.0 out of 20 for service and One&Only’s 17.2. The highest at Belmond: Belmond The Cadogan. At One&Only: One&Only Cape Town and One&Only The Palm.
Which has the better rooms, Belmond or One&Only?
Neither by much: Belmond’s hotels average 17.6 out of 20 for rooms & design and One&Only’s 17.7. The highest at Belmond: Belmond The Cadogan. At One&Only: One&Only Cape Town and three others.
Which has the better locations, Belmond or One&Only?
Neither by much: Belmond’s hotels average 17.7 out of 20 for location and One&Only’s 17.7. The highest at Belmond: Belmond Hotel Caruso and four others. At One&Only: One&Only Mandarina.
Which has the better restaurants, Belmond or One&Only?
Belmond: Belmond’s hotels average 17.6 out of 20 for dining and One&Only’s 16.5. The highest at Belmond: Belmond Hotel Caruso. At One&Only: One&Only The Palm.
Which has the better spas, Belmond or One&Only?
Neither by much: Belmond’s hotels average 17.0 out of 20 for wellness and One&Only’s 17.2. The highest at Belmond: Hotel Cipriani, A Belmond Hotel, Venice. At One&Only: One&Only The Palm and One&Only Reethi Rah.
How many Belmond and One&Only hotels are in the Fat Voyage collection?
Belmond has seven hotels in the collection (four Fat Legends and three Fat Favorites). One&Only has six hotels in the collection (two Fat Legends, three Fat Favorites and one Fat Approved).
Where do Belmond and One&Only both have a hotel?
Both have a hotel in the collection in Cape Town: in Cape Town, Belmond Mount Nelson and One&Only Cape Town.

