Brand against brand One&Only vs The Peninsula
Overall, there is little between them.
Peninsula for the service.
How their hotels score
Average, out of 20
Overall Level
Overall: One&Only 17.3 out of 20, Peninsula 17.4 out of 20.Service +0.5
Service: One&Only 17.2 out of 20, Peninsula 17.7 out of 20.Rooms & Design Level
Rooms & Design: One&Only 17.7 out of 20, Peninsula 17.3 out of 20.Location Level
Location: One&Only 17.7 out of 20, Peninsula 17.6 out of 20.Dining Level
Dining: One&Only 16.5 out of 20, Peninsula 16.7 out of 20.Wellness Level
Wellness: One&Only 17.2 out of 20, Peninsula 17.2 out of 20.Their hotels
One&Only 6 hotels in the collection
- One&Only Cape Town Fat Legend · 18/20
- One&Only The Palm Fat Legend · 18/20
- One&Only One Za’abeel Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- One&Only Reethi Rah Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- One&Only Mandarina Fat Favorite · 17/20
- One&Only Palmilla Fat Approved · 16/20
Opening next
- One&Only Antigua 2027
- One&Only Hudson Valley 2028
- One&Only Fiji 2029
- One&Only Courchevel 2030
The Peninsula 6 hotels in the collection
- The Peninsula Istanbul Fat Legend · 18/20
- The Peninsula Bangkok Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- The Peninsula London Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- The Peninsula Tokyo Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- The Peninsula Hong Kong Fat Favorite · 17/20
- The Peninsula Paris Fat Favorite · 17/20
Opening next
- The Peninsula Yangon Date to be announced
What fat travellers ask
Is One&Only better than Peninsula?
There is little between them: One&Only’s six hotels in the Fat Voyage collection average 17.3 out of 20 and Peninsula’s six average 17.4, less than half a point apart. The hotel matters more than the brand; the best of each are One&Only Cape Town and The Peninsula Istanbul.
Which has the better service, One&Only or Peninsula?
Peninsula: One&Only’s hotels average 17.2 out of 20 for service and Peninsula’s 17.7. The highest at One&Only: One&Only Cape Town and One&Only The Palm. At Peninsula: The Peninsula Bangkok.
Which has the better rooms, One&Only or Peninsula?
Neither by much: One&Only’s hotels average 17.7 out of 20 for rooms & design and Peninsula’s 17.3. The highest at One&Only: One&Only Cape Town and three others. At Peninsula: The Peninsula London.
Which has the better locations, One&Only or Peninsula?
Neither by much: One&Only’s hotels average 17.7 out of 20 for location and Peninsula’s 17.6. The highest at One&Only: One&Only Mandarina. At Peninsula: The Peninsula Istanbul and two others.
Which has the better restaurants, One&Only or Peninsula?
Neither by much: One&Only’s hotels average 16.5 out of 20 for dining and Peninsula’s 16.7. The highest at One&Only: One&Only The Palm. At Peninsula: The Peninsula Istanbul.
Which has the better spas, One&Only or Peninsula?
Neither by much: One&Only’s hotels average 17.2 out of 20 for wellness and Peninsula’s 17.2. The highest at One&Only: One&Only The Palm and One&Only Reethi Rah. At Peninsula: The Peninsula Istanbul and The Peninsula Tokyo.
How many One&Only and Peninsula hotels are in the Fat Voyage collection?
One&Only has six hotels in the collection (two Fat Legends, three Fat Favorites and one Fat Approved). Peninsula has six hotels in the collection (one Fat Legend and five Fat Favorites).

