How their hotels score
Average, out of 20
Overall Level
Overall: Belmond 17.9 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental 17.7 out of 20.Service Level
Service: Belmond 18.0 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental 18.0 out of 20.Rooms & Design Level
Rooms & Design: Belmond 17.6 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental 17.5 out of 20.Location Level
Location: Belmond 17.7 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental 17.5 out of 20.Dining Level
Dining: Belmond 17.6 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental 17.4 out of 20.Wellness Level
Wellness: Belmond 17.0 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental 16.9 out of 20.In the same city
Their hotels
Belmond 7 hotels in the collection
- Belmond Hotel Caruso Fat Legend · 18.5/20
- Belmond Mount Nelson Fat Legend · 18/20
- Belmond The Cadogan Fat Legend · 18/20
- Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence Fat Legend · 18/20
- Belmond Copacabana Palace Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Hotel Cipriani, A Belmond Hotel, Venice Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- La Residencia, A Belmond Hotel Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
Opening next
Mandarin Oriental 16 hotels in the collection
- Mandarin Oriental Lutetia, Paris Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental, Bangkok Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental, Hong Kong Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental, London (Hyde Park) Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental, Marrakech Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental, New York Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental, Paris Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental, Tokyo Fat Legend · 18/20
- Mandarin Oriental Bodrum Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Mandarin Oriental Downtown, Dubai Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Mandarin Oriental Jumeira, Dubai Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Mandarin Oriental, Costa Navarino Fat Favorite · 17.5/20
- Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London Fat Favorite · 17/20
- Mandarin Oriental, Istanbul (Bosphorus) Fat Favorite · 17/20
- Mandarin Oriental The Landmark, Hong Kong Fat Approved · 16.5/20
Opening next
- Mandarin Oriental Makati, Manila December 2026
- Mandarin Oriental, Suzhou Late 2026
- Mandarin Oriental, Hangzhou Spring 2027
- Mandarin Oriental Cristallo, Cortina 2027
What fat travellers ask
Is Belmond better than Mandarin Oriental?
There is little between them: Belmond’s seven hotels in the Fat Voyage collection average 17.9 out of 20 and Mandarin Oriental’s 16 average 17.7, less than half a point apart. The hotel matters more than the brand; the best of each are Belmond Hotel Caruso and Mandarin Oriental Lutetia, Paris.
Which has the better service, Belmond or Mandarin Oriental?
Neither by much: Belmond’s hotels average 18.0 out of 20 for service and Mandarin Oriental’s 18.0. The highest at Belmond: Belmond The Cadogan. At Mandarin Oriental: Mandarin Oriental, Bangkok and three others.
Which has the better rooms, Belmond or Mandarin Oriental?
Neither by much: Belmond’s hotels average 17.6 out of 20 for rooms & design and Mandarin Oriental’s 17.5. The highest at Belmond: Belmond The Cadogan. At Mandarin Oriental: Mandarin Oriental Lutetia, Paris and seven others.
Which has the better locations, Belmond or Mandarin Oriental?
Neither by much: Belmond’s hotels average 17.7 out of 20 for location and Mandarin Oriental’s 17.5. The highest at Belmond: Belmond Hotel Caruso and four others. At Mandarin Oriental: Mandarin Oriental Lutetia, Paris.
Which has the better restaurants, Belmond or Mandarin Oriental?
Neither by much: Belmond’s hotels average 17.6 out of 20 for dining and Mandarin Oriental’s 17.4. The highest at Belmond: Belmond Hotel Caruso. At Mandarin Oriental: Mandarin Oriental, Hong Kong and five others.
Which has the better spas, Belmond or Mandarin Oriental?
Neither by much: Belmond’s hotels average 17.0 out of 20 for wellness and Mandarin Oriental’s 16.9. The highest at Belmond: Hotel Cipriani, A Belmond Hotel, Venice. At Mandarin Oriental: Mandarin Oriental, Bangkok and three others.
How many Belmond and Mandarin Oriental hotels are in the Fat Voyage collection?
Belmond has seven hotels in the collection (four Fat Legends and three Fat Favorites). Mandarin Oriental has 16 hotels in the collection (nine Fat Legends, six Fat Favorites and one Fat Approved).
Where do Belmond and Mandarin Oriental both have a hotel?
Both have a hotel in the collection in London: in London, Belmond The Cadogan and Mandarin Oriental, London (Hyde Park).

