One&Only Reethi Rah is one of the largest resort islands in the Maldives, and it earns that size: twelve beaches, a lagoon view from the beach club that guests describe as feeling like they have the whole place to themselves, and a speedboat transfer that gets you there in 45 minutes flat, no overnight at the airport waiting on a seaplane slot. People who've done both call it the more relaxed, less trafficked alternative to the newer mega-resorts nearby. The butlers are the reason repeat guests keep coming back: one host tracked down a solution to a guest's health scare at night, another left a nightlight for a child scared of the dark, a third remembered a returning family's drink order down to the ginger tea. The spa gets named as one of the best its guests have ever visited, and the gym is absurdly well equipped for an island resort, which matters more than it sounds during rainy season.
None of that means the arrival experience is frictionless. One recent guest was charged a deposit rather than having it held, then waited two weeks for the refund; another was billed $730 for a foilboarding session they'd been told was included, only discovering the charge after the fact. A 2023 cycling accident involving a resort service vehicle drew a slow, thin response from management, according to the guest hurt in it, and a renovation that started in late 2025 was still unsettling the island's calm as of September 2026. None of this is universal; it shows up in a handful of reports rather than most of them, but at the rates here (rooms start well above £2,000 a night) it's worth going in with your invoices and inclusions confirmed in writing rather than taken on trust at check-in.
This is a honeymoon-and-family resort more than an intimate hideaway: it has the scale and the kids' club to prove it, and more than one guest specifically weighs it against Cheval Blanc Randheli for couples wanting something quieter. If you want a big island with real variety in restaurants and activities, a staff roster that notices the small stuff, and a beach that still manages to feel private despite the size, book it for the villas and the butlers who run them.