Compare

Side by side One&Only Mandarina vs One&Only The Palm

Overall, One&Only The Palm is the stronger stay.

One&Only The Palm for the service.

One&Only Mandarina

Riviera Nayarit, Mexico · One&Only

A cliffside jungle setting over a protected swimming bay delivers real seclusion, at the cost of buggy dependence and a quiet that doesn’t suit everyone.

A cliffside jungle resort of private treehouse villas above the Pacific in Riviera Nayarit, an hour from Puerto Vallarta.

Read the full verdict

One&Only The Palm

Dubai, UAE · One&Only

Butlers handle requests by text and remember guests across repeat stays, from late checkout to a found AED 9,000 handed straight to Lost & Found.

A low-rise beachfront resort at the tip of a Palm Jumeirah frond in Dubai, with villas, three pools, and a Guerlain Spa.

Read the full verdict

How they score

Out of 20

Overall +1

Overall: One&Only Mandarina 17 out of 20, One&Only The Palm 18 out of 20.

Service +3.5 Why

Service: One&Only Mandarina 15 out of 20, One&Only The Palm 18.5 out of 20.

One&Only Mandarina: Named butlers anticipate needs and smooth over room faults, but other guests describe scripted small talk, missed carts and complaints met with little urgency.

One&Only The Palm: Butlers handle requests by text and remember guests across repeat stays, from late checkout to a found AED 9,000 handed straight to Lost & Found.

Rooms & Design Level Why

Rooms & Design: One&Only Mandarina 18 out of 20, One&Only The Palm 18 out of 20.

One&Only Mandarina: Treehouse and cliff villas bring private plunge pools and jungle-ocean views, though open-air construction means cicadas, heat and no real indoor retreat.

One&Only The Palm: Rooms and bathrooms run large with private, quiet villas and grounds kept immaculate, and a decade-old room still reads well.

Location +0.5 Why

Location: One&Only Mandarina 18.5 out of 20, One&Only The Palm 18 out of 20.

One&Only Mandarina: A cliffside jungle setting over a protected swimming bay delivers real seclusion, at the cost of buggy dependence and a quiet that doesn’t suit everyone.

One&Only The Palm: The tip of the Palm feels private and worlds away from the city, though it’s a 40-minute airport transfer and prone to construction delays.

Dining +1.5 Why

Dining: One&Only Mandarina 16 out of 20, One&Only The Palm 17.5 out of 20.

One&Only Mandarina: Carao’s changing menu and the jetty’s shrimp tacos stand out, though menus lean heavily Mexican and one guest was charged for water at a restaurant.

One&Only The Palm: Breakfast is the standout, generous and fresh, backed by four restaurants, strong in-room dining and a hummus at Zest guests single out.

Wellness +1 Why

Wellness: One&Only Mandarina 17 out of 20, One&Only The Palm 18 out of 20.

One&Only Mandarina: The spa’s holistic treatments and four-hands massage impress, undercut by broken gym equipment, bugs in the cold plunge and daytime construction noise.

One&Only The Palm: The Guerlain Spa, recently redone, has skilled therapists and a calm space, though one guest found the steam room closed to men until 6pm.

Strengths and trade-offs

One&Only Mandarina

One&Only The Palm

Strengths of One&Only Mandarina

  • Treehouse villas built into the cliffside jungle with private plunge pools and unobstructed ocean views
  • One of the most private layouts in Mexican luxury travel, with standalone villas hidden from neighbors and common areas
  • A calm, protected swimmable bay and beach that guests consistently rate among the best they’ve encountered
  • Strong spa and fitness facilities set directly into the natural landscape
  • Kids club with genuine scale, including a butterfly farm and horseback riding, despite the property’s adults-leaning feel

Strengths of One&Only The Palm

  • Small scale (95 rooms) means staff genuinely learn returning guests’ preferences
  • Breakfast buffet and Zest restaurant draw specific, repeated praise for quality and variety
  • Recently renovated Guerlain Spa is calm and well-regarded
  • Villas with private pools and direct beach access suit families and honeymooners
  • Falconry displays and other grounds touches add character beyond the standard resort checklist

Trade-offs of One&Only Mandarina

  • Golf cart transport is the only way to get around and wait times regularly run 20 minutes or more
  • Food is good but not consistently exceptional given the price, with small portions and a heavily marked-up wine list
  • Service quality swings noticeably between stays, tied to reported staff turnover
  • Extras like bottled water, jet skis, and spa treatments carry aggressive upcharges

Trade-offs of One&Only The Palm

  • Located at the very tip of the Palm, meaning longer, less predictable transfer times to the airport and city
  • Room decor in some categories is showing roughly a decade of age
  • A billing mix-up with prepaid spa treatments left one guest double-charged
  • Steam room access is restricted to men only until 6pm, an odd scheduling limitation

Where they differ

Only at One&Only Mandarina

TropicalDesignMexican Design

Map showing the location of One&Only Mandarina
Riviera Nayarit, Mexico

Only at One&Only The Palm

Middle Eastern Design

Map showing the location of One&Only The Palm
Dubai, UAE
oneonly mandarina official 1oneonly mandarina official 3
One&Only Mandarina
oneonly the palm web 11oneonly the palm official 2
One&Only The Palm

The verdicts

One&Only Mandarina

What you find here is genuinely singular: a private plunge pool cut into cliffside jungle, an ocean view that most travellers who've been everywhere still call the best they've seen, and a level of privacy where you can walk your own grounds without another guest in sight. The architecture is not a marketing photo. Multiple stays confirm the villas hold up in person, and the beach and lagoon below are calm enough to swim without worry.

Where it costs you is everything between the villa and the rest of the resort. Nothing is walkable in real terms, so you're on a golf cart schedule, and that schedule breaks down often enough that it's not a fluke: guests have waited twenty, even sixty minutes for a pickup that was promised in ten, sometimes missing spa windows because of it. Food is good rather than transformative outside of Carao, portions run small for the price, and the wine list is a real gouge (a bottle you'd pay $100 for at home can run $700). Water gets billed unless you specifically ask for house filtered, and staff turnover shows up as inconsistency: some trips get a butler who anticipates everything, others get one who can't confirm a buggy or forgets a birthday. One serious account of a homophobic incident at check-in surfaced too, which the hotel should take seriously given how many guests here are queer couples.

Book it for the villas and the setting, not for flawless execution. If you want that same jungle-cliff geography with fewer of these headaches, some guests point across the road to the newer Rosewood, which is more walkable and a bit more consistent at breakfast, though it doesn't match the seclusion or the drama of these villas. For anyone who wants total privacy, real design, and can shrug off a cart that's late, this is one of the most beautiful rooms you can book in Mexico.

The full page on One&Only Mandarina

One&Only The Palm

This is a 95-room resort at the end of the Palm's furthest frond, and that smallness is the whole pitch: staff learn your name and your coffee order fast because there simply aren't that many rooms to track. One returning guest of eleven years, who's spent decades reviewing hotels professionally, called it the best in Dubai without qualifying it. That's a strong claim, but the pattern in the details backs it up: a host arranging a late checkout and a bottle of wine unprompted, a beach team setting up sunbeds before anyone asked, a manager tracking down a specific Middle Eastern dessert someone had only had once before, in Morocco.

The trade-off is geography and a bit of age. Being at the tip of the Palm means real distance: roughly 40 minutes from the airport, more if the causeway traffic or construction cooperates. The rooms themselves, per at least one recent stay, are showing about a decade of wear in the decor even though the bones remain handsome. The privacy that makes this place work is the same privacy that costs you convenience if you actually want to be near downtown or the Burj Khalifa. One odd scheduling quirk: the steam room is closed to men until 6pm, with no option to just book around it.

Book it for a honeymoon, a family week where you want a kids' club that actually delivers, or a couples reset where you don't want to see another hotel guest all week. The four restaurants and the breakfast buffet alone justify skipping the newer glass towers downtown. If you want to be five minutes from Dubai Mall, this isn't your hotel; if you want an actual escape that still counts as Dubai, it's hard to beat.

The full page on One&Only The Palm

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — One&Only Mandarina or One&Only The Palm?

One&Only Mandarina: A cliffside jungle setting over a protected swimming bay delivers real seclusion, at the cost of buggy dependence and a quiet that doesn’t suit everyone. One&Only The Palm: Butlers handle requests by text and remember guests across repeat stays, from late checkout to a found AED 9,000 handed straight to Lost & Found. Overall, One&Only The Palm is the stronger stay.

What’s the difference between One&Only Mandarina and One&Only The Palm?

One&Only Mandarina is ahead on where it puts you. One&Only The Palm is ahead on how you’re looked after. One&Only Mandarina adds Tropical, Design and Mexican Design; One&Only The Palm adds Middle Eastern Design. Both are tagged Beach, Architecture, Romantic, Wellness and Family.

Which is better for service, One&Only Mandarina or One&Only The Palm?

One&Only The Palm leads on this. One&Only Mandarina: Named butlers anticipate needs and smooth over room faults, but other guests describe scripted small talk, missed carts and complaints met with little urgency. One&Only The Palm: Butlers handle requests by text and remember guests across repeat stays, from late checkout to a found AED 9,000 handed straight to Lost & Found.

Which is better for dining, One&Only Mandarina or One&Only The Palm?

One&Only The Palm leads on this. One&Only Mandarina: Carao’s changing menu and the jetty’s shrimp tacos stand out, though menus lean heavily Mexican and one guest was charged for water at a restaurant. One&Only The Palm: Breakfast is the standout, generous and fresh, backed by four restaurants, strong in-room dining and a hummus at Zest guests single out.

Where are One&Only Mandarina and One&Only The Palm?

One&Only Mandarina is in Riviera Nayarit, Mexico; One&Only The Palm is in Dubai, UAE.

Which has more Michelin Keys, One&Only Mandarina or One&Only The Palm?

One&Only Mandarina, with Three Michelin Keys in the Michelin Guide’s 2026 hotel selection; One&Only The Palm holds Two Keys. The Keys come from the guide’s own anonymous inspections and are separate from the Fat Score.