Compare

Side by side Raffles The Palm Dubai vs Raffles Udaipur

Overall, the two are within a point of each other.

Raffles Udaipur for the location, Raffles The Palm Dubai for the rooms.

Raffles The Palm Dubai

Dubai, United Arab Emirates · Raffles

French-palace styling with chandeliers and marble runs through spacious, spotless rooms with walk-in wardrobes and big bathrooms.

A French palace-style resort on Palm Jumeirah with 389 rooms, private villas, and a private beach.

Read the full verdict

Raffles Udaipur

Udaipur, India · Raffles

A private island on Udai Sagar Lake reached by boat with a petal welcome.

A Raffles hotel set on its own island on Udai Sagar Lake in Udaipur, India, styled as a trader’s country estate.

Read the full verdict

How they score

Out of 20

Overall +0.5

Overall: Raffles The Palm Dubai 17 out of 20, Raffles Udaipur 17.5 out of 20.

Service Level Why

Service: Raffles The Palm Dubai 17 out of 20, Raffles Udaipur 17 out of 20.

Raffles The Palm Dubai: Reception spotted a boy’s birthday at check-in and had cake and balloons waiting, though staff cutbacks in 2026 left one minder running the kids’ club alone.

Raffles Udaipur: Butlers and housekeeping are named for birthday surprises and off-shift rescues, though one wedding guest chased missing toiletries and a bathtub fix that never came.

Rooms & Design +1 Why

Rooms & Design: Raffles The Palm Dubai 18 out of 20, Raffles Udaipur 17 out of 20.

Raffles The Palm Dubai: French-palace styling with chandeliers and marble runs through spacious, spotless rooms with walk-in wardrobes and big bathrooms, though a couple of guests found the amenities skimpy.

Raffles Udaipur: The 21-acre island estate has spacious marble-floored rooms and lake-view balconies, with one washbasin leak the only complaint on record.

Location +1 Why

Location: Raffles The Palm Dubai 17 out of 20, Raffles Udaipur 18 out of 20.

Raffles The Palm Dubai: A private beach and Palm Jumeirah views, with enough greenery and quiet to feel removed from Dubai’s pace, though the island’s layout can make traffic tricky.

Raffles Udaipur: A private island on Udai Sagar Lake reached by boat with a petal welcome, though the 40-minute, multi-transfer trip into Udaipur puts the city at arm’s length.

Dining +1 Why

Dining: Raffles The Palm Dubai 16 out of 20, Raffles Udaipur 17 out of 20.

Raffles The Palm Dubai: Le Jardin’s dinner buffet is fresh and varied, but several guests found breakfast limited, one frozen-tasting, and the Piazza menu has been cut in half.

Raffles Udaipur: Chef Ranchhod Maharaj cooks Rajasthani dishes tableside and shares recipes, though one stay found the food mediocre and the buffet repeats night to night.

Wellness +1 Why

Wellness: Raffles The Palm Dubai 16 out of 20, Raffles Udaipur 17 out of 20.

Raffles The Palm Dubai: The big, well-kept pool area has attentive lifeguards, but one guest left the spa steam room dizzy, with a racing heart, after a few minutes.

Raffles Udaipur: The gym has attentive trainers running complimentary PT and yoga, but one family found the pool unsupervised and unhygienic during a packed wedding weekend.

Strengths and trade-offs

Raffles The Palm Dubai

Raffles Udaipur

Strengths of Raffles The Palm Dubai

  • Staff repeatedly go out of their way, from a lost watch tracked down after checkout to spontaneous birthday surprises
  • Private beach and pool area with cabana seating draws consistent praise for space and comfort
  • Palm Jumeirah location with private beach access and Palm views
  • French palace-inspired design with heavy marble and gold detailing that commits fully to the theme
  • Villas offer serious scale, with multi-bedroom layouts over 10,000 square feet including private pools

Strengths of Raffles Udaipur

  • Butlers and housekeeping staff repeatedly go beyond their shift for guests, from birthday surprises to off-property rescues
  • Chef Ranchhod Maharaj’s Rajasthani dishes and the live-music breakfast buffet stand out as dining highlights
  • The island arrival by boat with a petal welcome sets a memorable tone from the first minute
  • Rooms are spacious with lake views, marble floors, and well-maintained gardens across the estate
  • Strong for weddings and family stays, with activities built to keep guests on property for days

Trade-offs of Raffles The Palm Dubai

  • Breakfast buffet quality is inconsistent and several guests call it below what the price and brand should deliver
  • Staffing has visibly thinned at the pool and kids’ club compared to past stays
  • The maximalist gold-and-marble design is divisive and some guests find it heavy-handed rather than elegant
  • Alcohol pricing and in-room amenities feel stingy relative to the room rate

Trade-offs of Raffles Udaipur

  • Getting into Udaipur city involves a buggy, a boat, and then a cab, which discourages sightseeing
  • Service can slip during full-occupancy periods like weddings, with slow room service and chased-up requests
  • The pool has gone unsupervised during busy periods, with guests ignoring basic hygiene norms

Where they differ

Only at Raffles The Palm Dubai

BeachUrbanArchitectureDesign

Map showing the location of Raffles The Palm Dubai
Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Only at Raffles Udaipur

HeritageCulinaryWellnessRajasthani Design

Map showing the location of Raffles Udaipur
Udaipur, India
raffles the palm dubai official 3raffles the palm dubai web 4
Raffles The Palm Dubai
raffles udaipur official 6raffles udaipur web 8
Raffles Udaipur

The verdicts

Raffles The Palm Dubai

Raffles The Palm sells a very specific fantasy: gold leaf, chandeliers, and a lobby that looks like nobody told it this is a 2021 build on an artificial island. Guests either love that or can't get past it. Everyone agrees on the staff: Alim at reception, Tonyson in F&B, a security manager named Bilal who personally tracked down a guest's lost watch after checkout.

Breakfast is the most common complaint, even from guests who loved everything else, with buffet items described as frozen-tasting or simply thin for the rate. One recent five-night guest found the gym underwhelming and the amenities skimped for a Raffles. A longtime regular wrote that loungers used to come with spread-out towels, iced water, and staff cleaning your sunglasses, and that none of that happens anymore because the property is running leaner than it used to, which shows up elsewhere too: a kids' club staffed by one person, a closed restaurant or two during slower periods, a half-hour stand at check-in despite a confirmed VIP booking. None of it is dealbreaker territory, but at this price it shouldn't need explaining away.

Book it for the Palm Jumeirah beach, the pool, and a design that commits fully to its own excess rather than playing it safe. Skip the steam room if you're sensitive to heat; one guest left dizzy after a few minutes. Anyone prioritising breakfast variety or a leaner, more restrained aesthetic would be happier at a Four Seasons or Fairmont elsewhere in Dubai; families and honeymooners who want a private-beach staycation feel will get exactly what they came for.

The full page on Raffles The Palm Dubai

Raffles Udaipur

Raffles Udaipur is the hotel you reach by boat, and that single fact shapes almost everything about staying there. The property sits on its own island in Udai Sagar Lake, backed by the Aravalli hills, and the arrival sets the tone: an electric boat crossing, rose petals, a welcome that more than one guest has called the best check-in of their life. Inside, the rooms run spacious with marble and stained-wood floors and balconies that look straight onto the water. The butlers and housekeeping staff are repeatedly the best part of the trip: one housekeeping manager walked a stranded guest back to the hotel on his own time after his shift had ended, and butlers have talked chefs into off-menu Rajasthani dishes and arranged surprise proposals with a garden tour and a song thrown in. Chef Ranchhod Maharaj's cooking gets singled out by name often enough that it reads as the kitchen's real strength, alongside a breakfast buffet with live instrumental music that several guests call the best start to a day they've had in India.

None of that means every stay runs smoothly. One wedding guest's birthday weekend involved missing toiletries, a bathtub fix that never arrived, and a butler who forgot to mention the Rajasthani thali needs ordering a day ahead — frustrating at the price, though a different butler fixed the birthday setup once given clear instructions. During a packed wedding weekend, one family found the pool unsupervised, with guests swimming in their clothes and no one enforcing basic hygiene. And the island setting cuts both ways: it's gorgeous, but getting into Udaipur proper means a buggy, a boat, and then a cab, which makes the property feel more like a self-contained world than a base for exploring the city.

Book this for the island itself, not as a launchpad for sightseeing — the on-property activities (archery, pottery, birdwatching, a nightly Rajasthani show) are built for people who'd rather not leave. Families do well here, with kids' facilities and staff who go out of their way for them, though it's worth checking which play-area activities carry extra charges before you arrive. Weddings clearly get the full treatment, almost unanimously so. For a few quiet nights with a chef worth asking for by name and a boat ride you'll remember, this is the one to book.

The full page on Raffles Udaipur

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — Raffles The Palm Dubai or Raffles Udaipur?

Raffles The Palm Dubai: French-palace styling with chandeliers and marble runs through spacious, spotless rooms with walk-in wardrobes and big bathrooms. Raffles Udaipur: A private island on Udai Sagar Lake reached by boat with a petal welcome.

What’s the difference between Raffles The Palm Dubai and Raffles Udaipur?

Raffles The Palm Dubai is ahead on the rooms. Raffles Udaipur is ahead on where it puts you. Raffles The Palm Dubai adds Beach, Urban, Architecture and Design; Raffles Udaipur adds Heritage, Culinary, Wellness and Rajasthani Design. Both are tagged Family and Romantic.

Which is better for rooms & design, Raffles The Palm Dubai or Raffles Udaipur?

Raffles The Palm Dubai leads on this. Raffles The Palm Dubai: French-palace styling with chandeliers and marble runs through spacious, spotless rooms with walk-in wardrobes and big bathrooms, though a couple of guests found the amenities skimpy. Raffles Udaipur: The 21-acre island estate has spacious marble-floored rooms and lake-view balconies, with one washbasin leak the only complaint on record.

Which is better for location, Raffles The Palm Dubai or Raffles Udaipur?

Raffles Udaipur leads on this. Raffles The Palm Dubai: A private beach and Palm Jumeirah views, with enough greenery and quiet to feel removed from Dubai’s pace, though the island’s layout can make traffic tricky. Raffles Udaipur: A private island on Udai Sagar Lake reached by boat with a petal welcome, though the 40-minute, multi-transfer trip into Udaipur puts the city at arm’s length.

Where are Raffles The Palm Dubai and Raffles Udaipur?

Raffles The Palm Dubai is in Dubai, United Arab Emirates; Raffles Udaipur is in Udaipur, India.