This is the hotel Rio measures every other hotel against, and the address does a lot of the work: you step out onto Copacabana Beach, and four restaurants on site mean you never have to brave the street at night if you don't want to. The 1923 Art Deco building, designed by Joseph Gire, still has the old casino turned into the theatre and ballroom, and the free guided tour of the property's history is worth doing even though it costs nothing. The pool is the best reason to book a room here, run so tightly during a full Carnival house that sunbed etiquette gets enforced with a little wooden tile and nobody seems to mind.
The trade-offs are priced into what you're actually getting. One longtime guest who stays often called the breakfast actively bad, unripe fruit in a country full of good fruit, tapiocas worse than a street cart, and said only the newly renovated rooms feel like a real Belmond. Another guest's week was wrecked by crunchy potatoes in the chicken soup and a wedding running music until midnight. The ongoing pool-wing expansion, which will add 63 larger rooms by the time it's done, has meant construction noise reaching some rooms and the main pool being partly offline for stretches. Ask for a renovated room and check what's under construction before you book rather than assuming the brand name covers it.
None of that cancels the thing that keeps people coming back. A guest celebrating a milestone birthday during a full-capacity Carnival week said the GM was visibly walking the property the entire stay, and that kind of presence shows up again in how staff handled a stressful situation for another guest, solved quietly and followed up on afterward. Book it for the location, the pool and the history, not for the food.