Compare

Side by side Belmond Copacabana Palace vs Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence

Overall, the two are within a point of each other.

Villa San Michele for the food.

Belmond Copacabana Palace

Rio de Janeiro, Brazil · Belmond

Staff get remembered by name for curated tours, a Shakira-crowd escort and a problem resolved with a follow-up letter and gift.

An Art Deco hotel on Copacabana Beach in Rio de Janeiro dating to 1923, with 205 rooms and suites and a Michelin-starred restaurant.

Read the full verdict

How they score

Out of 20

Overall +0.5

Overall: Belmond Copacabana Palace 17.5 out of 20, Villa San Michele 18 out of 20.

Service Level Why

Service: Belmond Copacabana Palace 18 out of 20, Villa San Michele 18 out of 20.

Belmond Copacabana Palace: Staff get remembered by name for curated tours, a Shakira-crowd escort and a problem resolved with a follow-up letter and gift, though a few guests hit rude doormen or wrong orders.

Rooms & Design +1 Why

Rooms & Design: Belmond Copacabana Palace 17 out of 20, Villa San Michele 18 out of 20.

Belmond Copacabana Palace: The Art Deco landmark is immaculately kept, with spacious, spotless suites looking onto the beach, though one guest found the unrenovated rooms dated.

Villa San Michele: The restored fifteenth-century monastery keeps its Renaissance façade and terraced cypress gardens, and after the refurbishment one guest had one of their best nights’ sleep.

Location +1 Why

Location: Belmond Copacabana Palace 17 out of 20, Villa San Michele 18 out of 20.

Belmond Copacabana Palace: Right on Copacabana beach with the promenade outside the door, though guests advise care on Rio’s streets and the free May concert out front draws millions.

Villa San Michele: Perched in the Fiesole hills with a sweeping view over Florence and the Duomo, a free shuttle covers the 20-30 minute drive into a centre that isn’t walkable.

Dining +2 Why

Dining: Belmond Copacabana Palace 16 out of 20, Villa San Michele 18 out of 20.

Belmond Copacabana Palace: A wide, fresh breakfast from buffet or kitchen and a fine Japanese dinner at MEE, though some guests found breakfast stale and the cold cuts poor.

Villa San Michele: Dinner on the loggia under the stars and breakfast with a view both get picked out as trip highlights, though one recent stay flagged undertrained restaurant service.

Wellness +0.5 Why

Wellness: Belmond Copacabana Palace 16.5 out of 20, Villa San Michele 17 out of 20.

Belmond Copacabana Palace: Pool service stayed sharp and attentive even at full Carnival capacity, but the main pool and gym have been disrupted by an ongoing renovation and construction noise.

Villa San Michele: The large pool has sweeping city views and a generous sunbathing area, and there’s a 24/7 gym and a Guerlain spa.

Strengths and trade-offs

Belmond Copacabana Palace

Villa San Michele

Strengths of Belmond Copacabana Palace

  • Directly on Copacabana Beach with the boardwalk at the door
  • Pool service holds up even at full Carnival capacity
  • Staff repeatedly step up on problems, from lost reservations to medical concerns
  • 1923 Art Deco building with real history, including a free guided tour
  • Front desk and concierge team build custom itineraries beyond the usual hotel desk

Strengths of Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence

  • A former monastery with a facade attributed to Michelangelo, set in cypress gardens above the city
  • Terrace and loggia dinners overlooking the Duomo, singled out as the highlight of entire Italy trips
  • Staff who deliver specific, personal touches: an anniversary flower arrangement, sunglasses recovered from a bush, an off-duty errand run before a flight
  • A 2026 renovation refreshed rooms and suites without losing the monastic character
  • Large pool, Guerlain Spa and gardens that make the hotel itself a reason to stay, not just a base

Trade-offs of Belmond Copacabana Palace

  • Breakfast quality is inconsistent, with several complaints about cold cuts, unripe fruit and bad pastries
  • Ongoing pool wing construction has disrupted the pool and some rooms
  • Unrenovated rooms are noticeably dated compared to the refreshed ones
  • Hotel-wide events and weddings can bring noise into common areas and some rooms

Trade-offs of Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence

  • A 20-30 minute drive or shuttle ride from central Florence, which cuts into spontaneous city days
  • At least one account of a cold, suspicious welcome at the entrance before check-in
  • Uneven service in the main restaurant on at least one occasion, including running out of the signature Florentine steak
  • Solo travelers have reported feeling like an afterthought at the table

Where they differ

Only at Belmond Copacabana Palace

UrbanBeachCulinary

Map showing the location of Belmond Copacabana Palace
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

Only at Villa San Michele

WellnessCountrysideTuscan

Map showing the location of Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence
Florence, Italy
belmond copacabana palace official 2belmond copacabana palace web 7
Belmond Copacabana Palace
villa san michele florence web 14villa san michele florence official 5
Villa San Michele

The verdicts

Belmond Copacabana Palace

This is the hotel Rio measures every other hotel against, and the address does a lot of the work: you step out onto Copacabana Beach, and four restaurants on site mean you never have to brave the street at night if you don't want to. The 1923 Art Deco building, designed by Joseph Gire, still has the old casino turned into the theatre and ballroom, and the free guided tour of the property's history is worth doing even though it costs nothing. The pool is the best reason to book a room here, run so tightly during a full Carnival house that sunbed etiquette gets enforced with a little wooden tile and nobody seems to mind.

The trade-offs are priced into what you're actually getting. One longtime guest who stays often called the breakfast actively bad, unripe fruit in a country full of good fruit, tapiocas worse than a street cart, and said only the newly renovated rooms feel like a real Belmond. Another guest's week was wrecked by crunchy potatoes in the chicken soup and a wedding running music until midnight. The ongoing pool-wing expansion, which will add 63 larger rooms by the time it's done, has meant construction noise reaching some rooms and the main pool being partly offline for stretches. Ask for a renovated room and check what's under construction before you book rather than assuming the brand name covers it.

None of that cancels the thing that keeps people coming back. A guest celebrating a milestone birthday during a full-capacity Carnival week said the GM was visibly walking the property the entire stay, and that kind of presence shows up again in how staff handled a stressful situation for another guest, solved quietly and followed up on afterward. Book it for the location, the pool and the history, not for the food.

The full page on Belmond Copacabana Palace

Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence

A restored fifteenth-century monastery on a hill above Florence, its facade traditionally attributed to Michelangelo, is not a normal hotel pitch, and the reviews back it up: people describe walking the cypress-lined grounds before dinner and forgetting they're 20 minutes from a city. The 2026 renovation refreshed junior suites and public rooms without stripping the monastic bones, and the *thing* people actually book it for is dinner on the loggia as the sun goes down over the Duomo. One couple got a jazz set on the terrace they hadn't asked for; a birthday guest got a staff member offering to help with a personal errand before their flight, on his own time. That's the register here: specific, staff-driven generosity rather than generic five-star polish.

The catch is real and worth pricing in before you book. You are up a hill in Fiesole, and the shuttle into Florence runs on its own schedule, fine if you want a slower trip, annoying if you're planning museum mornings and dinner reservations around it. One dinner review flagged a training gap in the restaurant staff, and a separate visitor described a genuinely unpleasant front-desk reception before they'd even checked in. A solo traveller also noted the staff kept treating a party of one as an oversight rather than a norm. None of this is the median experience, but it happens often enough that the location and the front door are the two places this can wobble.

Book a Garden Room in the main monastery, or the Limonaia Suite if the budget stretches, and treat Florence as a day trip rather than the point of the visit; some travellers even split their stay with a Four Seasons or Portrait property in the old town for exactly this reason. If you want to be walking distance from the Uffizi, stay in the city. If you want a week where the hotel itself is the destination, this is one of the two properties in Florence that people put in that category, and the dinner on the loggia alone justifies the drive up the hill.

The full page on Villa San Michele

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — Belmond Copacabana Palace or Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence?

Belmond Copacabana Palace: Staff get remembered by name for curated tours, a Shakira-crowd escort and a problem resolved with a follow-up letter and gift. Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence: Dinner on the loggia under the stars and breakfast with a view both get picked out as trip highlights.

What’s the difference between Belmond Copacabana Palace and Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence?

Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence is ahead on the food. Belmond Copacabana Palace adds Urban, Beach and Culinary; Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence adds Wellness, Countryside and Tuscan. Both are tagged Heritage, Architecture and Romantic.

Which is better for dining, Belmond Copacabana Palace or Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence?

Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence leads on this. Belmond Copacabana Palace: A wide, fresh breakfast from buffet or kitchen and a fine Japanese dinner at MEE, though some guests found breakfast stale and the cold cuts poor. Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence: Dinner on the loggia under the stars and breakfast with a view both get picked out as trip highlights, though one recent stay flagged undertrained restaurant service.

Which is better for rooms & design, Belmond Copacabana Palace or Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence?

Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence leads on this. Belmond Copacabana Palace: The Art Deco landmark is immaculately kept, with spacious, spotless suites looking onto the beach, though one guest found the unrenovated rooms dated. Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence: The restored fifteenth-century monastery keeps its Renaissance façade and terraced cypress gardens, and after the refurbishment one guest had one of their best nights’ sleep.

Where are Belmond Copacabana Palace and Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence?

Belmond Copacabana Palace is in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence is in Florence, Italy.

Which has more Michelin Keys, Belmond Copacabana Palace or Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence?

Belmond Copacabana Palace, with Two Michelin Keys in the Michelin Guide’s 2026 hotel selection; Villa San Michele, A Belmond Hotel, Florence, holds One Key. The Keys come from the guide’s own anonymous inspections and are separate from the Fat Score.