CompareNew York

Side by side Mandarin Oriental, New York vs The Peninsula New York

Mandarin Oriental, New York and The Peninsula New York, side by side — the detail is below.

How they score

Out of 20

Overall

Overall: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, The Peninsula New York Score pending.

Service Why

Service: Mandarin Oriental 19 out of 20, The Peninsula New York Not scored.

The Peninsula New York: Staff pull off small surprises like handwritten cards and anniversary champagne, though one long-time guest’s December stay saw a mishandled restaurant booking and a billing error.

Rooms & Design Why

Rooms & Design: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, The Peninsula New York Not scored.

Mandarin Oriental: High-floor rooms stay quiet with soaking tubs and rainfall showers, framed by Chihuly glass and park or river views from the sky lobby.

The Peninsula New York: Rooms run large for Manhattan with touch-screen controls and genuinely comfortable beds, but one guest flagged dated finishes and rusty balcony rails despite a recent renovation.

Location Why

Location: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, The Peninsula New York Not scored.

Mandarin Oriental: Columbus Circle puts Central Park across the street, the subway at the door, and a Whole Foods and mall downstairs, though downtown neighbourhoods are a real cab ride away.

The Peninsula New York: Fifth Avenue puts you a short walk from Central Park, Rockefeller Center and the flagship shops, with subway access close by.

Dining Why

Dining: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, The Peninsula New York Not scored.

Mandarin Oriental: In-room dining arrives fast and the wonton soup and steak get singled out often, but afternoon tea is hit or miss depending on the day and the server.

The Peninsula New York: Room service arrives plated like a restaurant meal, Mason Rose pours a serious wine list, and Clement beat expectations for at least one dinner.

Wellness Why

Wellness: Mandarin Oriental 17 out of 20, The Peninsula New York Not scored.

Mandarin Oriental: The 36th-floor lap pool over the Hudson and amethyst steam room came up as clean and peaceful, with one guest finding the water too cold.

The Peninsula New York: The rooftop pool and gym get used and liked for their 22nd-floor views, but one afternoon turned into an unsupervised kids’ free-for-all with no pushback from staff.

Strengths and trade-offs

Mandarin Oriental

The Peninsula New York

Strengths of Mandarin Oriental, New York

  • Staff remember returning guests by name and arrange personal surprises across multiple visits
  • Rooms on high floors are quiet, spacious and immaculately kept with strong Central Park or Hudson views
  • Columbus Circle location puts the park, subway, and a mall and grocery store within the same complex
  • In-room dining arrives quickly, with the wonton soup and steak dishes singled out often
  • The 36th-floor lap pool and amethyst steam room make for a genuine recovery stop between days out

Strengths of The Peninsula New York

  • Fifth Avenue location minutes from Central Park, Rockefeller Center and major shopping
  • Rooms run notably larger than typical Manhattan hotel rooms, with full touch-screen controls
  • Staff handle small requests and celebrations well, from handwritten notes to spontaneous upgrades
  • 22nd-floor rooftop pool and gym with strong city views
  • In-room dining praised at restaurant-level quality

Trade-offs of Mandarin Oriental, New York

  • Afternoon tea quality swings from a highlight to rushed and overpriced depending on the day
  • A handful of guests found their specific room tired or inconsistently maintained
  • Downtown neighbourhoods are a real 20-30 minute cab ride from the hotel
  • Front desk warmth has occasionally felt transactional rather than personal

Trade-offs of The Peninsula New York

  • One guest’s stay saw a string of mishandled requests: a wrong billing credit, a booking mix-up and an unresolved cold room
  • Some finishes, including balcony railings, show wear despite recent renovation work
  • Pool area can turn chaotic with unsupervised children and little staff intervention

Where they differ

1.0 km apart in a straight line, both in New York.

Only at Mandarin Oriental

DesignFamily

Only at The Peninsula New York

ArchitectureRomantic

mandarin oriental new york official 1mandarin oriental new york web 6
Mandarin Oriental
the peninsula new york web 6the peninsula new york web 4
The Peninsula New York

The verdicts

Mandarin Oriental, New York

Mandarin Oriental, New York sits directly on Columbus Circle, and that location does a lot of the work: Central Park starts at the front door, the subway is right there, and a Whole Foods and a small mall sit downstairs so you never have to go outside if the weather turns. But what keeps people coming back, by their own account, is the staff. One guest's flight got diverted mid-trip; the concierge stayed in touch through the whole delay, arranged a suite upgrade, and had wine and snacks waiting when they finally landed after 1am. Another guest, pregnant, had mentioned it once in passing, and came back to the room to find a bottle of non-alcoholic rosé waiting. A homesick kid got theatre-themed cookies baked specially by the pastry team. The staff consistency is the real case for this hotel, and it shows up across checked-in guests, pool attendants, and in-room dining alike.

The rooms back it up: high floors are quiet, the Hudson and Central Park views are genuinely spectacular, and the Chihuly glass in the lobby is worth a slow look on your way out. The 36th-floor lap pool over the river and the amethyst steam room are a legitimate reason to build in recovery time between meetings or museums. Afternoon tea is inconsistent — some guests call it the best in the city for the view and the storytelling from the servers, others found it rushed, overpriced for the portions, or oddly empty of other diners. Rooms have occasionally come in tired or with housekeeping misses, and at least one guest found the front desk experience transactional rather than warm. Rates sit well above $700 a night and climb fast for the better views, so this isn't a hotel that nickel-and-dimes you so much as one that prices confidently from the start.

Book it for a couple celebrating something, for parents who want a kid-friendly five-star without sacrificing the adults' evening, or for repeat New York visitors who've decided they're done rotating hotels. Skip the tea room if your downtown plans mean a 20-30 minute cab each way matters to you. For the park views and the staff who remember you, it's one of the better arguments in the city.

The full page on Mandarin Oriental

The Peninsula New York

The case for staying at The Peninsula New York starts with the address: Fifth Avenue, close enough to Central Park and Rockefeller Center that you stop checking a map. Rooms run larger than almost anywhere else in Manhattan, several guests compare them to private apartments rather than hotel rooms, and the touch-screen controls for lights and temperature actually work as advertised. What people remember most, though, is the small stuff staff do without being asked twice: a front desk director who had champagne and chocolate-covered strawberries sent up for an anniversary, a pool attendant who kept a toddler supplied with the right toys on a rainy afternoon.

It isn't flawless, and the renovation hasn't reached everywhere: one guest called the rooms dated despite being told they were recently redone, and another flagged rusty balcony railings as an eyesore on an otherwise polished building. A longtime repeat guest's December stay went sideways in a way that matters: a cold room the engineer couldn't actually fix, a restaurant reservation the concierge said couldn't be moved (the restaurant itself had no problem with it), a phantom booking nobody owned up to, and a breakfast credit that came out wrong on the bill. None of that is typical of what people report here, but it shows what a bad day looks like when the usual polish slips. The penthouse lounge drew a separate complaint for feeling thin on atmosphere and rushing people out before they'd finished a bottle.

This suits a couple celebrating something, or anyone who wants to walk out the door straight into Fifth Avenue shopping and still come back to a room big enough to actually relax in. Book it for the location and the room size, and let the staff handle the occasion you're celebrating.

The full page on The Peninsula New York

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — Mandarin Oriental, New York or The Peninsula New York?

Mandarin Oriental, New York and The Peninsula New York, side by side — the detail is below.

What’s the difference between Mandarin Oriental, New York and The Peninsula New York?

Mandarin Oriental, New York adds Design and Family; The Peninsula New York adds Architecture and Romantic. Both are tagged Urban, Wellness and Culinary.

Which is better for rooms & design, Mandarin Oriental, New York or The Peninsula New York?

They land level here. Mandarin Oriental, New York: High-floor rooms stay quiet with soaking tubs and rainfall showers, framed by Chihuly glass and park or river views from the sky lobby. The Peninsula New York: Rooms run large for Manhattan with touch-screen controls and genuinely comfortable beds, but one guest flagged dated finishes and rusty balcony rails despite a recent renovation.

Which is better for location, Mandarin Oriental, New York or The Peninsula New York?

They land level here. Mandarin Oriental, New York: Columbus Circle puts Central Park across the street, the subway at the door, and a Whole Foods and mall downstairs, though downtown neighbourhoods are a real cab ride away. The Peninsula New York: Fifth Avenue puts you a short walk from Central Park, Rockefeller Center and the flagship shops, with subway access close by.

Where are Mandarin Oriental, New York and The Peninsula New York?

Both are in New York, about 1.0 km apart — close enough that the choice is the hotel, not the neighbourhood.