Question 1

How are these Caribbean hotels ranked?

Accepted Answer

Every hotel here carries a Fat Score — a 0–20 rating across five dimensions, synthesized from the most active luxury-travel communities, editorial publications, and verified guest reviews, weighted by source credibility, depth and recency. The list re-ranks as fresh reviews come in. Right now 1 hotel carries the Caribbean tag, led by Eden Rock St Barths at 17/20.

Question 2

Are these scored or paid placements?

Accepted Answer

Scored, never paid. No hotel pays to appear here or to score higher — the ranking reflects what people who paid for their own stays actually said.

Best Caribbean luxury hotels

Eden Rock St Barths