CompareNew York

Side by side The Peninsula New York vs Waldorf Astoria New York

The Peninsula New York and Waldorf Astoria New York, side by side — the detail is below.

How they score

Out of 20

Overall

Overall: The Peninsula New York Score pending, Waldorf Astoria New York 18 out of 20.

Service Why

Service: The Peninsula New York Not scored, Waldorf Astoria New York 19 out of 20.

The Peninsula New York: Staff pull off small surprises like handwritten cards and anniversary champagne, though one long-time guest’s December stay saw a mishandled restaurant booking and a billing error.

Waldorf Astoria New York: Doormen, front desk and housekeepers get remembered by name for anticipating requests, from a surprised birthday shoutout to a comped bar tab after a billing slip.

Rooms & Design Why

Rooms & Design: The Peninsula New York Not scored, Waldorf Astoria New York 18 out of 20.

The Peninsula New York: Rooms run large for Manhattan with touch-screen controls and genuinely comfortable beds, but one guest flagged dated finishes and rusty balcony rails despite a recent renovation.

Waldorf Astoria New York: The Art Deco lobby, bronze elevator doors and mosaics were restored intact, and rooms run large for New York, though the bathrooms and closets stay tight even in suites.

Location Why

Location: The Peninsula New York Not scored, Waldorf Astoria New York 17 out of 20.

The Peninsula New York: Fifth Avenue puts you a short walk from Central Park, Rockefeller Center and the flagship shops, with subway access close by.

Waldorf Astoria New York: A Park Avenue Midtown address puts restaurants, landmarks and meetings within easy reach while the rooms inside still feel like a retreat from the street.

Dining Why

Dining: The Peninsula New York Not scored, Waldorf Astoria New York 17 out of 20.

The Peninsula New York: Room service arrives plated like a restaurant meal, Mason Rose pours a serious wine list, and Clement beat expectations for at least one dinner.

Waldorf Astoria New York: Lex Yard’s two levels and the after-dark Yoshoku both pair superb food with attentive servers, and the owner of Please Don’t Tell runs Peacock Alley’s cocktails.

Wellness Why

Wellness: The Peninsula New York Not scored, Waldorf Astoria New York 17 out of 20.

The Peninsula New York: The rooftop pool and gym get used and liked for their 22nd-floor views, but one afternoon turned into an unsupervised kids’ free-for-all with no pushback from staff.

Waldorf Astoria New York: The Guerlain spa is the brand’s largest, with an Arctic snow room and a well-lit yoga studio, alongside a roughly 10,000-square-foot gym.

Strengths and trade-offs

The Peninsula New York

Waldorf Astoria New York

Strengths of The Peninsula New York

  • Fifth Avenue location minutes from Central Park, Rockefeller Center and major shopping
  • Rooms run notably larger than typical Manhattan hotel rooms, with full touch-screen controls
  • Staff handle small requests and celebrations well, from handwritten notes to spontaneous upgrades
  • 22nd-floor rooftop pool and gym with strong city views
  • In-room dining praised at restaurant-level quality

Strengths of Waldorf Astoria New York

  • Staff across every department, from valet to concierge, singled out for going beyond what’s expected
  • Original Art Deco details preserved: bronze elevator doors, lobby mosaics, the Silver Corridor murals
  • Suites run genuinely large for Manhattan, with connecting options across most room categories
  • Guerlain Spa is the brand’s largest, with a snow-generating Arctic treatment room
  • Strong, specific dining: Lex Yard and Yoshoku both draw standout mentions

Trade-offs of The Peninsula New York

  • One guest’s stay saw a string of mishandled requests: a wrong billing credit, a booking mix-up and an unresolved cold room
  • Some finishes, including balcony railings, show wear despite recent renovation work
  • Pool area can turn chaotic with unsupervised children and little staff intervention

Trade-offs of Waldorf Astoria New York

  • No pool or hot tub, unusual for a renovation at this price point
  • Bathrooms and closets run tight even in suites
  • Park Avenue–facing rooms pick up street noise
  • Pre-arrival communication (incidentals, booking details) has lagged the in-person service

Where they differ

600 m apart in a straight line, both in New York.

Only at The Peninsula New York

RomanticWellness

Only at Waldorf Astoria New York

HeritageDesignFamily

the peninsula new york web 6the peninsula new york web 4
The Peninsula New York
waldorf astoria new york official 5waldorf astoria new york official 6
Waldorf Astoria New York

The verdicts

The Peninsula New York

The case for staying at The Peninsula New York starts with the address: Fifth Avenue, close enough to Central Park and Rockefeller Center that you stop checking a map. Rooms run larger than almost anywhere else in Manhattan, several guests compare them to private apartments rather than hotel rooms, and the touch-screen controls for lights and temperature actually work as advertised. What people remember most, though, is the small stuff staff do without being asked twice: a front desk director who had champagne and chocolate-covered strawberries sent up for an anniversary, a pool attendant who kept a toddler supplied with the right toys on a rainy afternoon.

It isn't flawless, and the renovation hasn't reached everywhere: one guest called the rooms dated despite being told they were recently redone, and another flagged rusty balcony railings as an eyesore on an otherwise polished building. A longtime repeat guest's December stay went sideways in a way that matters: a cold room the engineer couldn't actually fix, a restaurant reservation the concierge said couldn't be moved (the restaurant itself had no problem with it), a phantom booking nobody owned up to, and a breakfast credit that came out wrong on the bill. None of that is typical of what people report here, but it shows what a bad day looks like when the usual polish slips. The penthouse lounge drew a separate complaint for feeling thin on atmosphere and rushing people out before they'd finished a bottle.

This suits a couple celebrating something, or anyone who wants to walk out the door straight into Fifth Avenue shopping and still come back to a room big enough to actually relax in. Book it for the location and the room size, and let the staff handle the occasion you're celebrating.

The full page on The Peninsula New York

Waldorf Astoria New York

The 2026 reopening gave the Waldorf Astoria New York 375 rooms where it used to have over 1,400, and the trade shows up immediately: a junior suite now runs upward of 600 square feet, with a sitting area, desk and bar that older Manhattan hotels don't bother with. Pierre-Yves Rochon, who did the George V, restored the bronze elevator doors, the lobby mosaics and the Silver Corridor murals rather than papering over them, so the public rooms still look like 1931 while the guest rooms are unmistakably new. Staff get named constantly and specifically: a doorman walking a first-time guest's luggage in with real warmth, a front desk agent who found room for a family's 10th-birthday trip during the tennis tournament crush, a concierge who turned a casual question about hotel history into an hour-long private tour.

The catch is scale in the wrong places. Several guests flag the bathrooms and closets as tight even in suites, and one detailed report calls out bathroom tile that doesn't line up at the seams, a strange miss on a renovation this expensive. There's no pool, and no hot tub, which matters if that's part of how you unwind on a trip, though the Guerlain spa compensates somewhat with a treatment room that actually generates snow. Park Avenue–facing rooms get traffic noise, so ask for the other side if you're a light sleeper. One guest who has also stayed at Aman New York put it plainly: Aman's rooms and pool win on paper, but the Waldorf's service and food pull ahead for less money, and the public spaces here feel lived-in rather than hushed.

Book it if you want Art Deco history with modern rooms and don't need a pool or a sprawling bathroom. Families and pet owners get real consideration here, down to chef-prepared dog amenities and connecting rooms across nearly every category. If a pool is non-negotiable, that's a fair reason to look elsewhere; if it isn't, this is the Midtown stay worth the splurge.

The full page on Waldorf Astoria New York

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — The Peninsula New York or Waldorf Astoria New York?

The Peninsula New York and Waldorf Astoria New York, side by side — the detail is below.

What’s the difference between The Peninsula New York and Waldorf Astoria New York?

The Peninsula New York adds Romantic and Wellness; Waldorf Astoria New York adds Heritage, Design and Family. Both are tagged Urban, Architecture and Culinary.

Which is better for service, The Peninsula New York or Waldorf Astoria New York?

They land level here. The Peninsula New York: Staff pull off small surprises like handwritten cards and anniversary champagne, though one long-time guest’s December stay saw a mishandled restaurant booking and a billing error. Waldorf Astoria New York: Doormen, front desk and housekeepers get remembered by name for anticipating requests, from a surprised birthday shoutout to a comped bar tab after a billing slip.

Which is better for rooms & design, The Peninsula New York or Waldorf Astoria New York?

They land level here. The Peninsula New York: Rooms run large for Manhattan with touch-screen controls and genuinely comfortable beds, but one guest flagged dated finishes and rusty balcony rails despite a recent renovation. Waldorf Astoria New York: The Art Deco lobby, bronze elevator doors and mosaics were restored intact, and rooms run large for New York, though the bathrooms and closets stay tight even in suites.

Where are The Peninsula New York and Waldorf Astoria New York?

Both are in New York, about 598 m apart — close enough that the choice is the hotel, not the neighbourhood.

Which has more Michelin Keys, The Peninsula New York or Waldorf Astoria New York?

Waldorf Astoria New York, with Two Michelin Keys in the Michelin Guide’s 2026 hotel selection; The Peninsula New York holds One Key. The Keys come from the guide’s own anonymous inspections and are separate from the Fat Score.