CompareLondon

Side by side Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London vs The Peninsula London

Overall, the two are within a point of each other.

The Peninsula London for the rooms.

The Peninsula London

London, United Kingdom · The Peninsula

Rooms run large with walk-in dressing rooms, double-sink marble bathrooms and a Toto washlet, plus tech that actually works, from one-touch spa mode to an in-room printer.

A newly built Peninsula hotel in central London near Hyde Park Corner, with rooftop views toward Wellington Arch.

Read the full verdict

How they score

Out of 20

Overall +0.5

Overall: Mandarin Oriental Mayfair 17 out of 20, The Peninsula London 17.5 out of 20.

Service +0.5 Why

Service: Mandarin Oriental Mayfair 17 out of 20, The Peninsula London 17.5 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair: Front desk and concierge staff learn guests by name fast and child-proofed a room with gifts for a toddler, though one guest found the rooftop bar slow to notice a raised hand.

The Peninsula London: Staff mark birthdays and engagements with upgrades and handmade cake, and early check-in runs smoothly, but a courtyard confrontation over a bicycle and a botched transfer still happened.

Rooms & Design +2 Why

Rooms & Design: Mandarin Oriental Mayfair 17 out of 20, The Peninsula London 19 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair: Modern rooms have heated bathroom floors and windows that kept one guest’s stay quiet, though a later guest found the construction next door extremely noisy.

The Peninsula London: Rooms run large with walk-in dressing rooms, double-sink marble bathrooms and a Toto washlet, plus tech that actually works, from one-touch spa mode to an in-room printer.

Location Level Why

Location: Mandarin Oriental Mayfair 17 out of 20, The Peninsula London 17 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair: Set in Hanover Square in the middle of Mayfair but still feels private, with the Elizabeth line putting Heathrow about 40 minutes away.

The Peninsula London: Mayfair views over Wellington Arch and Hyde Park Corner read as central yet oddly residential, though the nearest tube is reached through a tired tunnel and neither entrance has a concierge waiting.

Dining +0.5 Why

Dining: Mandarin Oriental Mayfair 17 out of 20, The Peninsula London 16.5 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair: Breakfast and the Hanover bar’s cocktails are the strong points, though the hotel itself has just one restaurant and guests often eat out.

The Peninsula London: Canton Blue’s Peking duck and the breakfast pastries are the highlights, though breakfast lets some guests down, from hard bread to a long wait for a table.

Wellness Level Why

Wellness: Mandarin Oriental Mayfair 17 out of 20, The Peninsula London 17 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair: The calm, beautifully designed spa has individual jacuzzis and a 25-metre pool long enough for a proper swim, though one guest wanted warmer water.

The Peninsula London: The basement spa’s 25-metre pool plays underwater music, and one guest who swam there daily ranks the spa among the best at any hotel.

Strengths and trade-offs

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair

The Peninsula London

Strengths of Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London

  • Suites and residences share one entrance, giving the hotel a genuinely residential feel
  • The green Ming marble staircase and lobby art make it a destination even for coffee
  • Rooftop Hanover Bar draws consistent praise for cocktails and views
  • 25-metre subterranean pool and spa rated a real highlight, not an afterthought
  • Front desk and doormen frequently praised by name for warmth and attentiveness

Strengths of The Peninsula London

  • Entry-level rooms with walk-in closets, double-sink bathrooms and Toto washlets that feel like a junior suite elsewhere
  • Peninsula Time allows check-in as early as 6am and checkout as late as 6pm
  • 25-metre basement pool and spa rank among the best in the city
  • Complimentary house car fleet including Rolls-Royce covers short London journeys
  • Canton Blue’s Cantonese menu, including Peking duck, is a genuine dining destination

Trade-offs of Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London

  • Breakfast service has been reported as slow, with long waits for drinks and orders
  • Only one restaurant open, and only for breakfast, limiting on-property dining options
  • Pool and spa reception has been left unstaffed at points in the evening
  • One guest reported construction noise from an adjacent site

Trade-offs of The Peninsula London

  • Front-of-house attitude is inconsistent, with isolated reports of rude or confrontational staff toward cyclists and at the restaurant hostess stand
  • Breakfast execution varies, with reports of hard bread, underripe fruit and slow table turnover
  • The ground-floor restaurant crowds what could be a calmer, more intimate lobby
  • Pre-booked airport transfers have failed to show on time for at least two guests

Where they differ

1.4 km apart in a straight line, both in London.

Only at Mandarin Oriental Mayfair

Nothing the other doesn’t also offer.

Only at The Peninsula London

Culinary

Guest room at Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, LondonJazz bar at Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London
Mandarin Oriental Mayfair
the peninsula london web 7the peninsula london web 3
The Peninsula London

The verdicts

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London

A one-night stopover here gets you a marble staircase people stop to photograph mid-coffee, suites bigger than almost anything else this central, and a rooftop bar with proper skyline views. The building is new enough that everything still feels considered: heated bathroom floors, windows that block out street noise entirely, a spa with a 25-metre pool that guests swim proper laps in rather than just dip into. For a hotel with only 50 rooms, that scale of finish is rare, and it's the reason so many guests call it their favourite Mandarin Oriental in the group.

Where it costs you is consistency, not quality. The doormen and reception staff get singled out by name for genuine warmth, but breakfast service has been described as guests left ten or fifteen minutes without a drink order taken, and the pool/spa desk has been left unstaffed with no one to direct guests out at closing. The hotel restaurant is also only open for breakfast, so outside the rooftop bar and room service there's nowhere else on property to eat, which matters more here than at a hotel with three restaurants to fall back on. One guest also flagged construction noise from next door, though most stays don't mention it. None of this cancels the staff warmth guests report elsewhere in the building, but at this rate it's fair to expect it at every table, not most of them.

Book it if you want the newest, most residential-feeling luxury address in Mayfair and you're not fussy about breakfast running on time. If you want old-world grandeur and more room categories to choose from, Claridge's is the obvious comparison; if it's your only night in London and you just want a beautiful, quiet room near the Elizabeth line, this is the one worth the money.

The full page on Mandarin Oriental Mayfair

The Peninsula London

A base Deluxe room here comes in bigger than a junior suite at most London five-stars, with a walk-in closet, double sinks, a Toto washlet and tech that actually works rather than just looking expensive. The rooms are the strongest argument for booking, and "Peninsula Time" (check-in from 6am, checkout as late as 6pm) is a genuinely useful perk if your flight lands at dawn, though it's dependent on the hotel actually having a room free: one guest who arrived at 8:30am on a confirmed early check-in was sent to the spa to wait until past 11.

The flip side is a building still working out its own identity. The ground-floor restaurant eats into what should be an intimate lobby, afternoon tea service can be scattered with five different servers touching one table, and the Brooklands rooftop bar has drawn complaints about stingy cocktails for the price. Staff are named constantly and warmly by guests, but the same reports include a shockingly hostile encounter with a cyclist in the courtyard and a transfer car that failed to show at 4am before a Heathrow flight. None of this is normal for what guests are paying, but none of it is the norm either: most stays described here ran smoothly from arrival to checkout.

Book it for the room and the bathroom, not for a flawless front door every time. First-timers should push for a courtyard-facing room over city view if street noise matters, and anyone chasing round-the-clock polish with zero missteps might be happier at the Lanesborough's more traditional, old-world service style. For everyone else, this is still the best hotel room in London right now.

The full page on The Peninsula London

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London or The Peninsula London?

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London: Breakfast and the Hanover bar’s cocktails are the strong points. The Peninsula London: Rooms run large with walk-in dressing rooms, double-sink marble bathrooms and a Toto washlet, plus tech that actually works, from one-touch spa mode to an in-room printer.

What’s the difference between Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London and The Peninsula London?

Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London is ahead on the food. The Peninsula London is ahead on the rooms. The Peninsula London adds Culinary. Both are tagged Urban, Design, Architecture, Wellness and Romantic.

Which is better for rooms & design, Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London or The Peninsula London?

The Peninsula London leads on this. Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London: Modern rooms have heated bathroom floors and windows that kept one guest’s stay quiet, though a later guest found the construction next door extremely noisy. The Peninsula London: Rooms run large with walk-in dressing rooms, double-sink marble bathrooms and a Toto washlet, plus tech that actually works, from one-touch spa mode to an in-room printer.

Which is better for service, Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London or The Peninsula London?

The Peninsula London leads on this. Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London: Front desk and concierge staff learn guests by name fast and child-proofed a room with gifts for a toddler, though one guest found the rooftop bar slow to notice a raised hand. The Peninsula London: Staff mark birthdays and engagements with upgrades and handmade cake, and early check-in runs smoothly, but a courtyard confrontation over a bicycle and a botched transfer still happened.

Where are Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London and The Peninsula London?

Both are in London, about 1.4 km apart — close enough that the choice is the hotel, not the neighbourhood.

Which has more Michelin Keys, The Peninsula London or Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London?

The Peninsula London, with Three Michelin Keys in the Michelin Guide’s 2026 hotel selection; Mandarin Oriental Mayfair, London, holds Two Keys. The Keys come from the guide’s own anonymous inspections and are separate from the Fat Score.