Compare

Side by side Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como vs Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing

Overall, the two score the same.

Mandarin Oriental for the spa, Mandarin Oriental Qianmen for the rooms.

Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como

Lake Como, Italy · Mandarin Oriental

The floating lake pool and spa are the stay’s standout, with a heated indoor pool and thermal area thrown in.

A 19th-century lakeside villa on Lake Como with a floating infinity pool, three restaurants, and a spa reached by golf cart between buildings.

Read the full verdict

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing

Beijing, China · Mandarin Oriental

Each room is its own courtyard house inside the hutong, with a private garden or tea room, so the design argument is the layout itself.

A 42-suite courtyard hotel built into Beijing’s historic hutongs near Tiananmen Square, with its own Cantonese and Italian restaurants but no pool.

Read the full verdict

How they score

Out of 20

Overall Level

Overall: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental Qianmen 18 out of 20.

Service Level Why

Service: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental Qianmen 18 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental: Staff get credited for upgrades given unasked and small touches like a neatly wrapped charger cord, though one guest’s broken outdoor spa tub never got properly fixed despite four attempts.

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen: Butlers organise through a private group chat and deliver personal touches like a framed photo with a handwritten note or anniversary flowers at check-in.

Rooms & Design +1 Why

Rooms & Design: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental Qianmen 19 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental: The 19th-century villa and gardens draw consistent admiration for spacious, well-kept suites with lake views and proper turndown, with complaints limited to a once-looped 7am soundtrack and tired lobby restrooms.

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen: Each room is its own courtyard house inside the hutong, with a private garden or tea room, so the design argument is the layout itself.

Location +0.5 Why

Location: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental Qianmen 18.5 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental: A private lakeside estate with its own pier and gardens, though the free shuttle to Como town fills fast and there is little nearby for evenings.

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen: Built directly into the hutongs south of Tiananmen Square, close to the Forbidden City and Temple of Heaven while staying quiet inside its own alleys.

Dining Level Why

Dining: Mandarin Oriental 17 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental Qianmen 17 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental: L’Aria’s lobster salad and chocolate tortino and Co.mo’s truffle pizza get singled out, but some found the bistro’s cooking inconsistent and the portions and prices hard to justify.

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen: Yan Garden’s Cantonese cooking and the cocktails at Bar Tiao get singled out, but breakfast is repeatedly called thin for the price and Vicini disappointed at least one table.

Wellness +2 Why

Wellness: Mandarin Oriental 18 out of 20, Mandarin Oriental Qianmen 16 out of 20.

Mandarin Oriental: The floating lake pool and spa are the stay’s standout, with a heated indoor pool and thermal area thrown in, though one guest found the spa reception unfriendly and treatments pricey.

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen: The spa’s tea ceremony and sound healing sessions are well regarded, though there’s no pool and the complimentary tai chi class fell flat.

Strengths and trade-offs

Mandarin Oriental

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen

Strengths of Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como

  • Floating infinity pool set directly on the lake, widely called the best on Como
  • Staff praised for unscripted small gestures and quick, graceful fixes when things go wrong
  • Spacious lake-view suites with private terraces, several guests upgraded without asking
  • Private pier and shuttle service make getting to Como town and the station easy
  • Spa consistently singled out as among the best guests have experienced anywhere

Strengths of Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing

  • Private courtyard suites built directly into the Caochang Hutong, many with their own tea room or garden
  • Butler team coordinates through a private chat and delivers genuinely personal touches, from framed photos to handwritten notes
  • Steps from Tiananmen Square and the Forbidden City while remaining quiet and self-contained
  • Yan Garden’s Cantonese cooking and the cocktails at Bar Tiao stand out among on-property dining

Trade-offs of Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como

  • L’Aria is expensive for small portions, and the property has only three restaurants total
  • Check-in can run over an hour during busy periods
  • Breakfast buffet called underwhelming for the room rate
  • One guest’s private spa tub broke down repeatedly with no real resolution offered

Trade-offs of Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing

  • Breakfast is repeatedly described as thin for the price, with no buffet
  • No swimming pool on property
  • Dining at Vicini and the complimentary tai chi class have both disappointed individual guests

Where they differ

Only at Mandarin Oriental

LakeRomanticWellnessItalian Design

Map showing the location of Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como
Lake Como, Italy

Only at Mandarin Oriental Qianmen

UrbanCulinaryFamilyChinese Design

Map showing the location of Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing
Beijing, China
mandarin oriental lake como web 13mandarin oriental lake como web 12
Mandarin Oriental
mandarin oriental qianmen beijing web 5mandarin oriental qianmen beijing web 8
Mandarin Oriental Qianmen

The verdicts

Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como

The floating pool is the reason people book this hotel, and it earns the reputation: an infinity pool set right on the lake that sways faintly when boats pass, with sunset views few properties on Como can match. Rooms run from the original 19th-century villa to newer buildings across the grounds, and the spa and lake-view suites are the two things nobody comes away disappointed by. Staff get credited for small unscripted gestures, like wrapping a stray phone charger in a velcro tie or quietly swapping a broken itinerary without a fuss, and more than one guest got a free upgrade to a suite without asking.

Dinner is where the price tag stops making sense to people. L'Aria is well reviewed for the cooking but called out repeatedly for small portions at a high bill, and the property only has three restaurants, so a plainer dinner means a shuttle into Como town. Check-in can run over an hour at busy periods, breakfast is called underwhelming for a hotel at this level, and at least one stay was marred by a spa tub that broke down four separate times with no real fix offered. None of that is universal: most guests leave calling the service the best they've had on the lake, but it is worth knowing going in that the kitchen and the arrival process are the weak links in an otherwise tight operation.

Book it for the villa setting, the pool, and a spa that keeps pulling people back for repeat trips. Skip L'Aria for a big dinner unless the bill doesn't matter, and go in expecting to eat in Como town at least once. For a lake-view suite and a few days of not thinking about anything, this is still the one to beat on Como.

The full page on Mandarin Oriental

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing

This isn't a hotel block dropped into old Beijing, it's a set of courtyard houses built right into the hutongs south of Tiananmen Square, with a local family's front door a few steps from your own. That setup is the whole case: you get a private garden and often a tea room behind your own gate, then step outside into alleys where people are hanging laundry and kids are playing, and the hutong setting does something no conventional lobby-and-corridor hotel in the city can. Butlers run the stay through a group chat, and the personal gestures land well past the usual turndown chocolate: one guest got a framed photo of themselves taken casually on a bike ride, delivered that evening with a handwritten note.

Eat on property and the results split. Yan Garden's Cantonese cooking earns real praise, and Bar Tiao's cocktails get called out by name, but breakfast comes up short for what you're paying, several guests calling it thin on options with no buffet, and at least one dinner at Vicini landed flat. There's no pool, so anyone set on swimming should look elsewhere, and the tai chi class offered as a wellness extra isn't worth building a morning around. None of this undoes the welcome: it just means the kitchen and the spa menu aren't why you book.

This is for travellers who want Beijing's history under their feet rather than a view of it from a high floor, and who don't mind a short walk through a lived-in alley to reach their room. First-timers wanting total immersion in old Beijing will find nothing else in the city quite like it, while those who'd rather have a skyline and a pool might look toward one of Beijing's tower hotels instead. Book it for the courtyard, the butlers, and a version of the city most visitors never get close to.

The full page on Mandarin Oriental Qianmen

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como or Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing?

Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como: The floating lake pool and spa are the stay’s standout, with a heated indoor pool and thermal area thrown in. Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing: Each room is its own courtyard house inside the hutong, with a private garden or tea room, so the design argument is the layout itself.

What’s the difference between Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como and Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing?

Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como is ahead on the spa. Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing is ahead on the rooms. Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como adds Lake, Romantic, Wellness and Italian Design; Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing adds Urban, Culinary, Family and Chinese Design. Both are tagged Heritage and Architecture.

Which is better for wellness, Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como or Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing?

Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como leads on this. Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como: The floating lake pool and spa are the stay’s standout, with a heated indoor pool and thermal area thrown in, though one guest found the spa reception unfriendly and treatments pricey. Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing: The spa’s tea ceremony and sound healing sessions are well regarded, though there’s no pool and the complimentary tai chi class fell flat.

Which is better for rooms & design, Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como or Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing?

Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing leads on this. Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como: The 19th-century villa and gardens draw consistent admiration for spacious, well-kept suites with lake views and proper turndown, with complaints limited to a once-looped 7am soundtrack and tired lobby restrooms. Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing: Each room is its own courtyard house inside the hutong, with a private garden or tea room, so the design argument is the layout itself.

Where are Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como and Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing?

Mandarin Oriental, Lake Como is in Lake Como, Italy; Mandarin Oriental Qianmen, Beijing is in Beijing, China.