CompareMarrakech

Side by side Amanjena vs El Fenn

Amanjena for the service.

Amanjena

Marrakech, Morocco · Aman

A host had superglue bought for one guest and an off-duty host rebooked another’s flights.

A secluded Aman resort in Marrakech’s Palmeraie, built around reflecting pools and pisé-walled pavilions outside the medina.

Read the full verdict

El Fenn

Marrakech, Morocco

Right in the medina with the Koutoubia visible from the rooftop, a quiet perch above a loud city.

A boutique riad hotel in the Marrakech medina known for its rooftop restaurant, bar and views of the Koutoubia.

Read the full verdict

How they score

Out of 20

Overall

Overall: Amanjena 17.5 out of 20, El Fenn Not in collection.

Service +5.5 Why

Service: Amanjena 19 out of 20, El Fenn 13.5 out of 20.

Amanjena: A host had superglue bought for one guest and an off-duty host rebooked another’s flights; staff use guests’ names, though one visitor felt treated harshly over photos.

El Fenn: A woman using a wheelchair was refused the lift and mocked by managers, and a manager would not speak to another guest hurt by a waiter.

Rooms & Design +1.5 Why

Rooms & Design: Amanjena 17.5 out of 20, El Fenn 16 out of 20.

Amanjena: Rose-hued pisé walls, reflecting pools and palm-lined courtyards win people over, though several 2025 stays flagged pavilions as dated despite renovation.

El Fenn: The rooftop’s red-and-white tiles and pendant lamps are striking, though tables sit close enough to be knocked as people pass.

Location +0.5 Why

Location: Amanjena 17.5 out of 20, El Fenn 17 out of 20.

Amanjena: Set outside Marrakech in its own palm grove, away from the Medina’s noise, which trades walkable souks for a private, quiet compound.

El Fenn: Right in the medina with the Koutoubia visible from the rooftop, a quiet perch above a loud city, though the hotel itself gets little comment.

Dining +3 Why

Dining: Amanjena 16.5 out of 20, El Fenn 13.5 out of 20.

Amanjena: Arva’s vitello tonnato and cacio e pepe and the poolside wood-fired pizza stand out, though some guests find much of the cooking average.

El Fenn: The lamb shank, sea bass and chocolate fondant get singled out, but tables routinely wait up to 90 minutes for food that never gets cleared between courses.

Wellness Level Why

Wellness: Amanjena 16 out of 20, El Fenn 16 out of 20.

Amanjena: The hammam and treatments are relaxing and the pavilion pools private, though one guest found the spa dated and another the gym short on equipment.

El Fenn: There’s a rooftop pool at the restaurant and bar, but no spa or treatments to speak of on property.

Strengths and trade-offs

Amanjena

El Fenn

Strengths of Amanjena

  • Staff learn guest names and preferences within a day and follow through without prompting
  • Pool pavilions offer real privacy with private plunge pools and courtyards
  • The Italian restaurant Arva is consistently called the best meal on property
  • Genuinely quiet, low-density grounds set apart from Marrakech’s chaos
  • Excursions like the Atlas Mountains hike and vintage sidecar ride are well organized

Strengths of El Fenn

  • Striking red-and-white Moroccan interiors across the rooftop restaurant and bar
  • Rooftop views over the medina to the Koutoubia minaret
  • Standout dishes including sea bass, octopus, beef and lamb shank
  • A quiet, central location in the heart of the medina

Trade-offs of Amanjena

  • Spa and hammam are dated, with at least one report of a fungus issue in a shower
  • Room renovations are inconsistent, so some villas still run wifi and hot water problems
  • The property has occasionally closed key facilities (restaurant, spa, main pool) with little advance warning
  • Food outside Arva is unremarkable for the price, especially breakfast and the Moroccan restaurant’s kitchen

Trade-offs of El Fenn

  • Long waits for food and drinks, sometimes over an hour
  • Serious lapses in how complaints and accessibility requests get handled
  • Small, pricey menu with limited à la carte choice at some sittings
  • Tightly packed rooftop tables

Where they differ

6.0 km apart in a straight line, both in Marrakech.

Only at Amanjena

DesertWellnessArchitectureMoroccan Design

Only at El Fenn

UrbanDesignCulinary

Amanjena: the main poolAmanjena: the courtyard and pool of a Maison Jardin
Amanjena
el fenn marrakech official 8el fenn marrakech room 3
El Fenn

The verdicts

Amanjena

Amanjena is the quiet Marrakech Aman, built around reflecting pools, pisé walls and enough distance from the medina that outside of breakfast you might not see another guest. That isolation is the whole pitch, and it delivers: guests describe walking the grounds at dusk with nobody around, staff who learn names within a day, and a level of anticipation that shows up in small things, like a team sourcing superglue at midnight or setting up satellite cable for a tennis final within minutes of being asked. The service is the reason people keep coming back, and it's consistent enough across stays years apart that it reads as house culture rather than luck.

Book it knowing the building has aged unevenly. A 2025 post-renovation stay found new lighting, a Toto washlet and a proper gym where the library used to be; another guest that same month, in an unrenovated villa, spent three days without wifi or hot water. The spa is the softest part of the property — several recent reviews call it outdated, and one flagged actual fungus in a shower, which is hard to excuse at these rates. Food is fine rather than exceptional apart from Arva, the Italian spot; the Moroccan restaurant is worth one dinner for the atmosphere and live music, not the cooking. Check ahead of booking, too: guests have arrived to find the spa, restaurant or library closed for works with only a buried pop-up as warning.

This suits couples and honeymooners who want stillness over spectacle, and travellers with small children may find it a bit sleepy, several reports mention kids getting bored by day two. Anyone chasing the more theatrical, palace-scale Moroccan experience tends to end up talking about Royal Mansour instead. But for a few days of genuine quiet outside Marrakech, with a private pool villa and a staff that remembers your order by the second morning, Amanjena still earns its place.

The full page on Amanjena

El Fenn

El Fenn is a riad-turned-boutique-hotel in the Marrakech medina, and most people who write about it are actually describing one evening on its rooftop: red tiles, pendant lamps swaying over the courtyard, the Koutoubia minaret in view as the sun goes down. The design is the draw and it earns that reputation honestly, with a distinct, colourful style that feels considered rather than decorated-to-order. The sea bass and octopus get singled out, the beef and lamb shank too, and more than one traveller has walked in for a quick cocktail and stayed for dinner instead.

Get past the view and the kitchen and it gets uneven fast. Tables arrive forty, sixty, ninety minutes after ordering; one couple waited so long for mains that the staff brought out a birthday cake before the food ever showed, and charged full price anyway. That's a pattern worth pricing in if you're booking a special occasion rather than a casual drink. Far more serious is how complaints get handled: a woman with mobility difficulty was refused lift access and mocked by managers for asking, and a guest hit in the eye by a waiter couldn't get a manager to so much as acknowledge it. Prices sit well above most of Marrakech, and at those prices the kitchen's quiet-night triumphs (the chocolate fondant, that lamb shank) have to compete with slow, careless front-of-house nights.

This is a hotel worth visiting for an evening even if you're staying elsewhere in the medina: go for a rooftop drink, stay if the food and the room both land, and go in knowing the night could go either way. Book the stay itself for the design and the setting, not for anyone looking after you at the door.

The full page on El Fenn

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — Amanjena or El Fenn?

Amanjena: A host had superglue bought for one guest and an off-duty host rebooked another’s flights. El Fenn: Right in the medina with the Koutoubia visible from the rooftop, a quiet perch above a loud city.

What’s the difference between Amanjena and El Fenn?

Amanjena is ahead on how you’re looked after. Amanjena adds Desert, Wellness, Architecture and Moroccan Design; El Fenn adds Urban, Design and Culinary. Both are tagged Romantic and Heritage.

Which is better for service, Amanjena or El Fenn?

Amanjena leads on this. Amanjena: A host had superglue bought for one guest and an off-duty host rebooked another’s flights; staff use guests’ names, though one visitor felt treated harshly over photos. El Fenn: A woman using a wheelchair was refused the lift and mocked by managers, and a manager would not speak to another guest hurt by a waiter.

Which is better for dining, Amanjena or El Fenn?

Amanjena leads on this. Amanjena: Arva’s vitello tonnato and cacio e pepe and the poolside wood-fired pizza stand out, though some guests find much of the cooking average. El Fenn: The lamb shank, sea bass and chocolate fondant get singled out, but tables routinely wait up to 90 minutes for food that never gets cleared between courses.

Where are Amanjena and El Fenn?

Both are in Marrakech, about 6.0 km apart — close enough that the choice is the hotel, not the neighbourhood.