Four Seasons Resort Mallorca at Formentor vs Four Seasons Landaa Giraavaru

The old Hotel Formentor was rebuilt as a Four Seasons, and the reports agree the flag earned its name: the service goes well beyond a script. Guests describe handwritten notes waiting at every table, a GM who checks in mid-stay unprompted, birthday surprises that clearly weren't templated. Shima, the Japanese-Peruvian restaurant, comes up in nearly every account as reason enough to book, vegetarian tasting menu included. Mel, the second restaurant, is more of a mixed bag: good food, but portions that can feel thin for what you're paying on an off night.

The peninsula itself is the real cost of staying here. One guest counted 183 cyclists and 16 tour buses on a five-mile stretch of the only access road, and said it made her husband refuse to drive after dark, cancelling every dinner they'd planned off property. With just two restaurants on site, that road turns anything beyond four or five nights into a repeat-menu problem. A hotel boat to Port Pollença helps, but wasn't running full service as of last season. Scattered complaints about AC and tech glitches, plus one 30-minute luggage wait after a personal welcome, read as opening-year teething rather than a pattern worth knowing before you book.

Families come away particularly convinced, with several ranking it alongside Borgo Egnazia and Marbella Club for that specific trip, praising warmth for kids that never curdles into a kids'-resort vibe. Book this for four nights, plan the road into your itinerary rather than around it, and let Shima do the rest.

The case for Landaa Giraavaru starts with the atoll, not the villa. Baa is a UNESCO Marine Biosphere Reserve, and serious divers keep saying the same thing: staying inside it beats commuting to it from anywhere near Malé. Guests who've done both Four Seasons properties, and both Maldives brands, routinely rate Landaa's rooms and service ahead of the Ritz-Carlton Fari Islands — one detailed comparison called the Ritz's villas "basic for the price" with pools too shaded to actually use, while Landaa's larger rooms and more natural service kept coming up favorably. The manta-phone system is real: guests staying early October describe getting pulled off a meal mid-course for a sighting. A diver who stayed the first week of November got the phone, the wait, and nothing. Migratory animals don't run on a checkout calendar, and the resort is honest about that itself.

Where the pitch gets shakier is right off your own deck. A recent dive-literate guest called the house reef basically nonexistent next to other Maldives stays, which stings more here than most places given how hard the marine-life story is sold — you're booking boat snorkeling, not step-off-the-jetty coral. Dining draws a real split: multiple guests rave about the restaurants across the property, but an experienced Maldives hand flagged thin variety and no meal-plan option, a genuine gap against competitors who offer one. Staff, by contrast, come up as the standout in nearly every account, named individually often enough to trust it, and the Four Seasons app as a same-day-response team beats a single butler more often than not.

Worth booking if the atoll and the diving are the real trip, not scenery for one; travelers chasing a stronger house reef tend to weigh Anantara Kihavah instead. For the room, the service, and a sandbar you can walk out to at low tide, Landaa earns its place.