Compare

Side by side Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva vs Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

Overall, the two are within a point of each other.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze for the service.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

Florence, Italy · Four Seasons

Staff get called by name and remember personal details, with a manager arranging a tour and a concierge rebooking a rental car drop-off.

A Renaissance palazzo hotel in Florence set within eleven acres of private gardens near the historic centre.

Read the full verdict

How they score

Out of 20

Overall +0.5

Overall: Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva 18 out of 20, Four Seasons Hotel Firenze 18.5 out of 20.

Service +1 Why

Service: Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva 18 out of 20, Four Seasons Hotel Firenze 19 out of 20.

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva: Housekeeping leaves baked treats and gifts daily and the concierge set up a pasta class for one family’s children, though walk-in visitors describe being refused empty tables.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze: Staff get called by name and remember personal details, with a manager arranging a tour and a concierge rebooking a rental car drop-off; one guest’s lost pool tote was handled poorly.

Rooms & Design +0.5 Why

Rooms & Design: Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva 18 out of 20, Four Seasons Hotel Firenze 18.5 out of 20.

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva: Rooms carry original 1834 detail with fresh renovations in a soft blue palette and in-room hammam showers, but several guests found them cramped for the price and the shower heads dated.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze: Frescoed ceilings and antique floors sit alongside a newly opened wing and refreshed rooms, though summer AC has struggled to cool some rooms and one sofa bed only folds to a single.

Location Level Why

Location: Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva 18.5 out of 20, Four Seasons Hotel Firenze 18.5 out of 20.

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva: Right on the lake by the bridge into the Old Town, with the station, shopping and sightseeing all a walk away yet the hotel itself stays quiet.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze: A walled eleven-acre garden keeps city noise out while the centre stays an eight-to-fifteen-minute walk or hourly shuttle away, though it’s further from the Uffizi than hotels right downtown.

Dining +0.5 Why

Dining: Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva 18 out of 20, Four Seasons Hotel Firenze 17.5 out of 20.

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva: Izumi’s rooftop Japanese cooking and an outstanding breakfast stand out, though a currency dispute and a reformulated profiterole drew complaints.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze: Breakfast runs from custom chef plates to a full bread spread, and Il Palagio’s Michelin-starred cooking anchors the property, though poolside food and some signature cocktails landed flat for a few.

Wellness Level Why

Wellness: Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva 17 out of 20, Four Seasons Hotel Firenze 17 out of 20.

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva: The top-floor spa and pool get natural light and skyline views, with two steam rooms at different temperatures and a well-liked therapist named Maria.

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze: A big garden pool, a gym with all-new kit, steam and sauna, and a top-notch spa, though one July guest found the pool overrun with toddlers.

Strengths and trade-offs

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

Strengths of Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva

  • 1834 building with original frescoes, chandeliers and a recent room renovation
  • Izumi, the top-floor Japanese restaurant, called the best meal in Geneva by multiple guests
  • Lakefront location by the bridge to the Old Town, near the station and shopping
  • Top-floor spa and pool with two steam rooms and in-room hammam showers
  • Doormen and housekeeping singled out repeatedly for warmth and speed

Strengths of Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

  • Eleven-acre private garden that blocks out the city entirely
  • Frescoed ceilings and Renaissance architecture throughout the palazzo
  • Staff consistently remembered guests by name across multiple visits
  • Michelin-starred Il Palagio plus a strong breakfast buffet
  • Large pool and one of Florence’s biggest hotel spas

Trade-offs of Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva

  • Restaurant host stand mishandles walk-ins at busy hours, holding empty tables while guests wait
  • Historic-wing rooms run small and showerheads underwhelm for the nightly rate
  • A reworked profiterole recipe and a pricey asparagus starter drew specific complaints

Trade-offs of Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

  • A genuine fifteen-to-twenty-minute walk from the historic center, not a short stroll
  • Air conditioning has struggled to keep up during peak summer heat in some rooms
  • At least one guest reported an unusually aggressive suite upsell at check-in
  • Poolside food and the standard breakfast buffet run simpler than the rest of the property

Where they differ

Only at Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva

CulinaryRomantic

Map showing the location of Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva
Geneva, Switzerland

Only at Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

FamilyItalian Design

Map showing the location of Four Seasons Hotel Firenze
Florence, Italy
Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva, photo 1Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva, photo 2
Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva
four seasons firenze official 6four seasons firenze official 4
Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

The verdicts

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva

This is the oldest hotel in Geneva, built in 1834 on the lake, and it mostly still acts like it: the frescoes and gilded ceilings are original, the rooms were recently redone, and the top-floor Japanese restaurant, Izumi, keeps coming up as the best meal in the city, not just the best meal in the building. The doormen and valet get named repeatedly for making the arrival feel unhurried, and housekeeping shows up fast when called, sometimes leaving a small baked treat behind for no reason anyone asked for. The spa, also on the top floor, has proper natural light, two steam rooms at different temperatures, and an in-room hammam shower that nobody else in town bothers with.

Rooms in the historic wing run small for what you're paying in Swiss francs, and a few guests flagged the showerheads as underwhelming for the price. Where it actually slips is the restaurant floor at busy hours: more than one guest describes empty tables held as "reserved" while they waited fifteen minutes for a menu, or got seated after people who arrived later. A returning bar regular also noted the kitchen swapped out a beloved profiterole recipe for a stiffer, worse version, which is a strange thing to mess with when everything else on the menu is being called excellent. The bar itself is a genuine draw on its own, with a bartender who'll remake a cocktail without being asked twice.

None of that touches the case for the room and the location, which is unmatched in Geneva: on the lake, by the bridge to the Old Town, walkable to everything. Book it for a couple of nights in a renovated room and dinner at Izumi, and go in expecting the lobby to occasionally move slower than the price suggests it should.

The full page on Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

The garden is the thing: eleven acres of it, walled off from the rest of Florence, with pheasants and a Renaissance chapel tucked inside, turning a stay in a loud, crowded city into something closer to a week at a country estate. The palazzo itself earns the comparison too: frescoed ceilings, carved stone, courtyards that guests keep calling a living museum, and that's before the newer rooms in Palazzo del Nero, which manage to feel fresh without losing the character. The staff are the other half of the case - concierge teams tracking down last-minute Uffizi tickets in peak season, a waiter at the pool restaurant who gets remembered by name years later, a front desk that replaced a too-firm mattress without a fuss.

Price it in honestly: this is a twenty-minute walk from the historic centre, not the five-minute stroll some other Florence addresses offer, and a few travellers who prioritise being in the thick of it count that against the hotel. One guest's honeymoon check-in involved a surprisingly pushy suite upsell that read as tone-deaf rather than discreet, and the air conditioning has drawn more than one complaint in peak summer heat, loud enough in at least one room to disrupt sleep. None of that is rare at this price point, but it's worth knowing before you book a room without confirming the AC is working properly.

Book it for families: the garden, the pool, and a staff that treats children like actual guests make this one of the easiest full-luxury stays in Italy with kids in tow. Solo travellers or couples chasing a five-minute walk to the Duomo might be happier elsewhere in the city, but for anyone who wants a retreat that still puts Florence within reach, this is the one to pick.

The full page on Four Seasons Hotel Firenze

Where to stay next, in your inbox.

Newsletter

You’ll get the new hotels and the openings worth booking early, plus longer reads, like which room to ask for or whether a famous name still deserves the trip.

— Nicolas

What fat travellers ask

Which should I book — Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva or Four Seasons Hotel Firenze?

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva: Izumi’s rooftop Japanese cooking and an outstanding breakfast stand out. Four Seasons Hotel Firenze: Staff get called by name and remember personal details, with a manager arranging a tour and a concierge rebooking a rental car drop-off.

What’s the difference between Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva and Four Seasons Hotel Firenze?

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva is ahead on the food. Four Seasons Hotel Firenze is ahead on how you’re looked after. Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva adds Culinary and Romantic; Four Seasons Hotel Firenze adds Family and Italian Design. Both are tagged Urban, Heritage, Architecture and Wellness.

Which is better for service, Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva or Four Seasons Hotel Firenze?

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze leads on this. Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva: Housekeeping leaves baked treats and gifts daily and the concierge set up a pasta class for one family’s children, though walk-in visitors describe being refused empty tables. Four Seasons Hotel Firenze: Staff get called by name and remember personal details, with a manager arranging a tour and a concierge rebooking a rental car drop-off; one guest’s lost pool tote was handled poorly.

Which is better for rooms & design, Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva or Four Seasons Hotel Firenze?

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze leads on this. Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva: Rooms carry original 1834 detail with fresh renovations in a soft blue palette and in-room hammam showers, but several guests found them cramped for the price and the shower heads dated. Four Seasons Hotel Firenze: Frescoed ceilings and antique floors sit alongside a newly opened wing and refreshed rooms, though summer AC has struggled to cool some rooms and one sofa bed only folds to a single.

Where are Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva and Four Seasons Hotel Firenze?

Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva is in Geneva, Switzerland; Four Seasons Hotel Firenze is in Florence, Italy.

Which has more Michelin Keys, Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva or Four Seasons Hotel Firenze?

Four Seasons Hotel Firenze, with Three Michelin Keys in the Michelin Guide’s 2026 hotel selection; Four Seasons Hotel des Bergues Geneva holds Two Keys. The Keys come from the guide’s own anonymous inspections and are separate from the Fat Score.